Controversial Penalty Call Mars Palmeiras’ Victory Over São Paulo in Paulista Semifinal

Palmeiras secured a 2-1 victory over São Paulo in the Campeonato Paulista semifinal on Saturday, March 1st, 2026, but the match was overshadowed by a contentious penalty decision. The incident, involving a potential handball by Palmeiras captain Gustavo Gómez, has ignited debate among fans and analysts.

Match Recap

Palmeiras opened the scoring with a goal from Maurício in the 7th minute. Flaco López extended the lead in the second half before São Paulo’s Calleri responded with a goal in the 23rd minute, adding tension to the closing stages of the match. However, the pivotal moment occurred earlier in the second half when Lucas Moura’s shot appeared to strike Gómez’s arm within the penalty area.

The Controversial Incident

As Lucas Moura fired a shot towards the goal, the ball made contact with the arm of Gustavo Gómez, who was attempting to block the attempt. São Paulo players immediately appealed for a penalty, and coach Hernán Crespo emphatically gestured to the referee. However, the on-field referee, Daiane Caroline Muniz dos Santos, waved play on, and the VAR did not recommend a review.

Expert Analysis

Renata Ruel, a commentator for ESPN, believes a penalty should have been awarded. She explained that while Gómez attempted to withdraw his arm, he expanded his body, creating space for the ball to strike it. According to Ruel, despite inconsistent officiating, a penalty would typically be called in such a situation in Brazilian football. ESPN

The decision drew strong criticism from São Paulo, with coach Crespo stating, “The images speak for themselves.” The club’s executive of football, Rui Costa, was tasked with formally protesting the decision to avoid potential suspension for Crespo. R7 Esportes

VAR Intervention and Refereeing Directives

Reports indicate that the Comissão de Arbitragem da FPF (São Paulo State Football Federation Arbitration Commission) had recommended a decrease in VAR intervention for the 2026 season, with the on-field referee’s decision intended to be given more weight. However, some argue that this directive was applied excessively in this instance, leading to a significant injustice. R7 Esportes

Palmeiras Advances to the Final

Despite the controversy, Palmeiras advanced to the final of the Campeonato Paulista, where they will face Novorizontino. This marks Palmeiras’ seventh consecutive appearance in the Paulista final under coach Abel Ferreira. CNN Brasil

The first leg of the final will be played at Palmeiras’ home stadium, with the second leg taking place in Novo Horizonte.