“Price increases are occurring nationally, but not nearly as quickly as New York,” said Joshua Macey, a professor at Yale Law School who studies energy policy.
Between August 2019 and August 2026, residential electricity prices in New York rose almost 56%, while the national price rose 36.5%, Macey said, citing data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. More than 70% of New Yorkers surveyed by Siena University said high utility costs hurt their finances.
Con Edison data for New York City show that single-family homes spend $218 a month on average for energy, up from roughly $144 before the pandemic. Upstate customers of New York State Electric and Gas saw average monthly bills more than double, to $147 from $71 in 2019, Spectrum News reported.
Three drivers push costs higher
Macey identified three drivers: high infrastructure costs nationwide, rising commodity costs in a state where building new supply is difficult, and energy policies that flow directly into ratepayer bills.
Kevin Lanahan, senior vice president for external affairs at the New York Independent System Operator, said the grid has lost about 1,750 megawatts of older generating units that retired or stopped producing for much of the year after stricter emissions rules required them to install new equipment or shut down.
“We’ve got less supply on the system, but the demand is going up, and so the cost of that commodity has also risen,” Lanahan said.
Indian Point closure removed a quarter of city power
The 2017 agreement by then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo to close the Indian Point nuclear plant in Westchester took effect in 2021 and removed 25% of the electricity consumed by New York City. That gap was filled largely by fossil-fuel generation. “[The state] was not building new infrastructure while resources were retiring,” Macey said. “That’s going to contribute to rate increases.”
Reliability warnings for the early 2030s
NYISO projects significant reliability deficiencies beginning in 2032 or 2033. “We need to take action right now in order to meet what we have pinpointed will be significant reliability deficiencies starting in 2032 or 2033,” Lanahan said.
Policy shifts under Hochul
Gov. Kathy Hochul has delayed some clean-energy mandates and approved the long-stalled Northeast Supply Enhancement pipeline, a natural-gas link to Pennsylvania. Macey said the state should scrutinize utility capital spending more carefully to ensure upgrades occur at low cost and consider viable alternatives.
Constellation runs three upstate nuclear plants
Constellation operates three upstate nuclear plants, including Nine Mile Point in Oswego County, providing about 20% of the state’s power and nearly half its emissions-free electricity. The company receives a state subsidy paid by utility customers, about $400 million a year, extended by regulators through 2049 in January.
“We’re generating 20% of the power supply of New York state and almost half of New York’s clean, emissions free power,” said Mark Rodgers of Constellation. He said the plants run better today than when the first unit started in 1988.
Critics say the subsidy locks in costs for bills already among the highest in the country. Constellation is bidding to host the first new nuclear plant in decades, but Rodgers acknowledged the risk: “There’s not a great appetite to absorb the risk of developing those first of a kind projects. So it’s going to take a number of parties working together, public-private interactions to get that combination right.”
Keep reading