The Wisconsin attorney general race features a high-stakes rematch between Democratic incumbent Josh Kaul and Republican challenger Eric Toney, highlighting starkly different visions for the state’s top legal office. According to state election filings and campaign announcements, the contest centers heavily on public safety, reproductive rights, and the administration of election laws.
Josh Kaul and the Democratic Platform
Josh Kaul took office in January 2019 after defeating incumbent Republican Brad Schimel. According to campaign statements and official office records, Kaul has prioritized protecting reproductive healthcare access, expanding the state’s crime lab capacity, and addressing gun violence. During his tenure, Kaul joined multi-state legal challenges to defend the Affordable Care Act and has been an outspoken advocate for maintaining the integrity of Wisconsin’s election processes.
Eric Toney and the Republican Platform
Eric Toney serves as the district attorney for Fond du Lac County, a position he has held since 2013. According to his campaign platform, Toney focuses his messaging on aggressive prosecution, supporting law enforcement agencies, and criticizing Kaul’s handling of violent crime rates across Wisconsin. Toney secured the Republican nomination after emphasizing his courtroom experience as a prosecutor and pledging a tougher approach to state law enforcement priorities.
Key Issues Shaping the Attorney General Race
Voters in Wisconsin face clear policy distinctions between the two candidates on several major fronts:

- Abortion Access: Kaul has repeatedly stated his refusal to enforce Wisconsin’s 1849 abortion ban following the overturn of Roe v. Wade, whereas Toney has argued that prosecutors have a duty to uphold state statutes enacted by the legislature.
- Crime and Public Safety: Toney contends that crime has risen under Kaul’s watch, pointing to prosecution metrics in various counties. Kaul’s campaign highlights investments in local police departments and state-level forensic testing backlogs.
- Election Administration: Both candidates hold contrasting views regarding the oversight of elections, with debates centering on the role of the Department of Justice in advising local election officials.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the Wisconsin attorney general election?
According to the Wisconsin Elections Commission, the election takes place on November 3.

Who are the main candidates?
The race features Democratic incumbent Josh Kaul and Republican challenger Eric Toney, according to candidate filings.
What are the primary responsibilities of the Wisconsin Attorney General?
According to the Wisconsin Department of Justice, the attorney general leads the state agency, represents Wisconsin in court, provides legal opinions to state agencies, and enforces state laws.
Keep reading