Nashua Woman Indicted in Connection With Teen’s Drowning at Lake Winnipesaukee

A 50-year-old Nashua, New Hampshire, woman is facing multiple criminal charges following an investigation into the death of a 17-year-old teenager at Lake Winnipesaukee. The incident, which occurred last summer, has led to a formal indictment as authorities move forward with legal proceedings.

Details of the Charges

Buffy Ann Doyle was indicted on four separate charges in connection with the teenager’s death, which reportedly took place on June 20, 2025. According to New Hampshire state police, the charges include:

• Felony negligent homicide
• Two counts of witness tampering
• Falsifying physical evidence

Officials allege that Doyle provided alcohol to the teenager and permitted him to enter the water while he was intoxicated. Following his entry into the lake, the teen struggled to swim, went underwater, and did not resurface.

Investigation Findings

The investigation into the drowning has been ongoing for several months. Initial reports provided to law enforcement by three women on the boat indicated that the teenager had entered the water in an attempt to retrieve a bag that had fallen overboard. The incident occurred in an area of the lake known as The Broads, situated near Diamond and Rattlesnake Islands.

Doyle was arraigned on Tuesday and entered a plea of not guilty to all four charges. She has since been released on personal recognizance and is scheduled to return to court on June 26, 2026.

Key Takeaways

• Legal Status: The defendant has pleaded not guilty to charges of negligent homicide, witness tampering, and falsifying physical evidence.
• Incident Context: The death occurred on June 20, 2025, during an outing on Lake Winnipesaukee.
• Allegations: Authorities claim the defendant allowed an intoxicated minor to enter the water after providing him with alcohol.

Moving Forward

As the legal process continues, the case highlights the critical importance of safety protocols and responsible supervision during recreational water activities. With the court date set for late June, the community and the families involved await further developments in this ongoing judicial matter.

Note: This report is based on information provided by New Hampshire state authorities and local news coverage of the indictment.