The average employer-sponsored family health plan now costs $28,303, a sum that equals 44 percent of the typical full-time worker’s pre-tax cash wages, Fortune reported.
Workers typically see about a quarter of that premium deducted from their paychecks and assume the employer covers the rest, but economists have documented for decades that rising fringe benefits crowd out cash wage growth, Fortune reported. When total compensation is fixed, every dollar spent on health insurance is a dollar not paid in wages.
“The rude shock is that workers pay all of it,” wrote Tony Lo Sasso, professor of public affairs at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, in the Fortune commentary. Employers think in terms of total compensation — wages, leave, retirement, workers’ compensation and health benefits — not individual buckets, he said.
Roughly 100 million people receive coverage from large companies that self-insure, meaning the employer pays medical bills directly rather than buying insurance, Fortune reported. In that model, insurers act as hired administrators, shifting the focus to how benefit designs and vendor contracts are negotiated.
Consultant incentives favor higher spending
Most large self-insured employers rely on a handful of major benefits consultants to design plans and contract with vendors, Fortune reported. Those consultants often earn more when employer spending rises — through commissions tied to premiums or side payments from recommended vendors — creating a structural conflict of interest.
Federal law requires brokers and consultants to disclose direct and indirect compensation, but not necessarily how incentive structures work, Fortune reported.
Discounts off inflated charges mask real prices
The standard approach to measuring hospital value relies on discounts off billed charges, yet hospital charges are widely recognized as inflated values set by the hospitals themselves and charged to virtually no one, Fortune reported.
Highmark, a Blue Cross plan, illustrates the distortion in its own employer materials: a facility that charges $100 and gives a 60 percent discount is paid $40, while one that charges $70 and gives a 50 percent discount is paid $35, Fortune reported. The larger discount costs more.
Actuarial firm Milliman notes that charges rise faster than negotiated prices, so discounts appear to grow even as actual prices increase, Fortune reported. The same dynamic appears in out-of-network repricing — where vendors take a percentage of “savings” off billed charges, as a 2024 investigation of MultiPlan documented — and in drug rebates tied to manufacturer list prices, Fortune reported. In every case, the reward goes to whoever sets the highest list price.
Corporate benefits staff face asymmetric risk
Benefits departments avoid changes that might generate complaints because they bear all the downside risk and none of the upside, Fortune reported. If a plan change goes wrong, the CEO hears about it; if it saves millions, the staff gets no credit.

Workers’ share of the cost is spread across 26 paychecks — a few hundred dollars per period — making it minimally salient, Fortune reported. This creates concentrated blame for any disruption and diffuse, hidden costs for the status quo.
Founded in 1848 when Wisconsin achieved statehood, the University of Wisconsin–Madison is the flagship campus of the University of Wisconsin System and a public land-grant research university. It is the historic home of the “Wisconsin School” of economics and the “Wisconsin Idea,” articulated in 1904, which holds that the university’s boundaries should extend to the boundaries of the state. The campus ranked fifth among U.S. universities in research expenditures in 2024.
Steps employers can take without new legislation
Lo Sasso outlined a CFO-level agenda to restructure incentives:
- Bring finance to the table. Treat the health plan like any other major line item, with the same scrutiny of contracts, prices and vendor margins.
- Change the benchmark. Use health care price transparency data to compare negotiated prices against an external standard such as a multiple of Medicare rates. Medicare prices are a benchmark, not an aspirational target.
- Pay consultants a flat, disclosed fee. Eliminate commissions tied to premiums and side payments from recommended vendors.
- Make employees partners. Commit up front that savings will appear as lower contributions and higher take-home pay, and report the numbers annually.
Keep reading