WWE Had Plans for David Finlay Before His AEW Debut

David Finlay’s recent debut in All Elite Wrestling (AEW) has quickly made waves, but it appears World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) also had plans for the former New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW) star before he ultimately signed with Tony Khan’s promotion. Finlay made a significant impact during the March 4, 2026, episode of AEW Dynamite, attacking Darby Allin and Orange Cassidy after a tag team match alongside Gabe Kidd and Clark Connors, officially forming the faction known as “The Dogs.”

WWE’s Interest and Creative Plans

According to reports, WWE had internally discussed potential creative directions for Finlay had he chosen to join the company. Finlay’s desire to perform more frequently in the United States, influenced by a recent personal change – the birth of his child – played a role in his decision-making process. He wanted a schedule that allowed him to be home more often, and American wrestling promotions generally offer more consistent schedules than those in Japan. [Source: Ringside News]

WWE reportedly envisioned Finlay as a leader within NXT, specifically heading a group of second-generation wrestlers. This group would have included Lexis King (son of Brian Pillman), Stacks Lorenzo, Arianna Grace (daughter of Santino Marella), and Uriah Connors (Brogan Finlay, David’s younger brother). [Source: Sports Illustrated]

Finlay Chooses AEW

Despite WWE’s plans, Finlay ultimately chose to debut in AEW, aligning himself with Kidd and Connors to form “The Dogs.” Tony Khan officially announced that Finlay, Connors, and Kidd had all signed contracts with AEW following his debut. [Source: MSN] The deal with AEW reportedly came together quickly, finalized within the last week of February 2026, after Finlay became a free agent on February 16, 2026. [Source: Sports Illustrated]

The Dogs in AEW

With the formation of “The Dogs,” AEW has introduced a new faction poised to play a significant role in upcoming storylines. The group’s debut signals a new direction for all three wrestlers as they initiate their run in AEW. [Source: Sportsnaut]