International Edition
Latest News
Business

Wyoming Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss School-Choice Lawsuit

District Court Judge Peter Froelicher denied a motion to dismiss the lawsuit challenging Wyoming’s Steamboat Legacy Scholarship Program on Nov. 6, keeping the legal battle over the state’s school-choice law active. The litigation, which includes the Wyoming Education…

Wyoming Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss School-Choice Lawsuit

District Court Judge Peter Froelicher denied a motion to dismiss the lawsuit challenging Wyoming’s Steamboat Legacy Scholarship Program on Nov. 6, keeping the legal battle over the state’s school-choice law active.

The litigation, which includes the Wyoming Education Association and a group of parents as plaintiffs, seeks to block the program that provides up to $7,000 in state funds to students for private K-12 education expenses. Defendants, including Superintendent of Public Instruction Megan Degenfelder and State Treasurer Curt Meier, had asked the court to dismiss the case by arguing the plaintiffs lacked standing to sue.

“We remain confident in the strength of our case and steadfast in our belief that public dollars belong in public schools,” said Kimberly Amen, president of the Wyoming Education Association, in a statement to WyoFile.

The central legal question remains whether the Steamboat Legacy Scholarship Program violates the Wyoming Constitution. The state constitution prohibits the use of public funds for private and parochial schools and limits state expenditures to the "necessary support of the poor," a mandate the plaintiffs argue the 2025 law ignores.

Wyoming Education Daily — November 16, 2026: The Program Pays While the Court Decides — Education Across the States

The program, which covers tuition, admission fees for educational activities, and homeschooling materials, expands school choice in the state. Lawmakers previously established an income-qualified voucher system in 2024, but Rep. Ocean Andrew, R-Laramie, pushed for the broader 2025 expansion, arguing the previous iteration was too narrow.

While the district court’s recent ruling allows the case to proceed toward trial, the program’s path has been marked by shifting judicial decisions. Froelicher initially granted a preliminary injunction in July 2025 to halt the program, but the Wyoming Supreme Court reversed that decision in May. The higher court concluded that the plaintiffs had failed to demonstrate they would suffer a personal, irreparable injury from the program.

Despite the Supreme Court’s decision, school-choice advocates expressed little surprise at the district court’s latest move. “The district court’s denial of our motion for judgment on the pleadings in order to wait for further evidence will not change the governing law in this case,” said Litigation Thomas M. Fisher, director of litigation for EdChoice, who represents families intervening in the case.

When the state first opened applications for the Steamboat Legacy Scholarship in 2025, nearly 4,000 students applied for the 2025/26 school year. The program includes provisions for pre-K costs, limited to families earning at or below 250% of the federal poverty level—approximately $80,000 annually for a family of four.

Opponents of the law argue that the scholarship program diverts essential funding from public schools. They contend that as students move to private alternatives, declining enrollment will lead to smaller state budget apportionments for public districts, potentially impacting the quality of education for those who remain.

What is the current status of the program’s funding?
The program is currently active following the Wyoming Supreme Court’s reversal of the initial injunction in May. Families are continuing to accrue costs for private-school expenses that the state has pledged to fund.

Who are the primary defendants in the lawsuit?
The lawsuit names the State of Wyoming, Superintendent of Public Instruction Megan Degenfelder, and State Treasurer Curt Meier as defendants.

What is the next step in the court process?
The case will move toward trial, where the district court will evaluate whether the program adheres to constitutional requirements regarding the funding of public education.

About the author: Marcus Liu - Business Editor

MBA and ex‑B bureau chief specializing in global finance and fintech. Marcus speaks Mandarin, Japanese, and English, and has interviewed CEOs from the Fortune 50 to Y‑Combinator unicorns. Marcus Liu delivers sharp analysis on markets, startups, and corporate strategy for investors and entrepreneurs alike.