The Fight That Sparked the Debate

The match at the Intuit Dome in California was billed as a showcase for Netflix’s foray into MMA, but it quickly became a lightning rod for controversy. Critics—primarily from social media—accused the fight of being “rigged,” pointing to Carano’s decision to turn away from the armbar rather than submit. However, MMA insiders and former training partners dismissed these claims as baseless, citing Rousey’s decades-long dominance in the sport.

“If you want to know how swift the memory of MMA fans gets erased, 17 seconds isn’t even her fastest win, and people think it was worked.”

— Shayna Baszler, former MMA fighter and Rousey’s training partner

Baszler, who transitioned to professional wrestling and later won the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship in 2023, took to social media to address the skepticism. In a tweet, she reminded fans of Rousey’s record: nine wins under a minute, including finishes in 14 seconds (against Cat Zingano) and 16 seconds (against Alexis Davis). “All of as someone who trained with Ronda Rousey, none of those textbook armbar escapes really work against her armbar anyway,” Baszler added in a follow-up video.

Why the Armbar Remains Unbeatable

Rousey’s armbar isn’t just about speed—it’s about precision. MMA analysts attribute her success to three key factors:

  • Technical Mastery: Rousey’s armbar is executed with surgical precision, often catching opponents off-guard with a combination of feints and rapid transitions.
  • Psychological Edge: Opponents often hesitate to submit due to the stigma of tapping to a woman, giving Rousey the upper hand in mental warfare.
  • Adaptability: Her armbar has evolved over the years, incorporating submissions from various positions (e.g., mount, half-guard) to counter defensive adjustments.

Former UFC fighter Holly Holm, who lost to Rousey in 2015, once called her armbar “the most devastating weapon in MMA.” The sentiment persists among fighters who’ve faced her.

Rousey’s Retirement: A Full-Circle Moment

After the fight, Rousey delivered an emotional post-match speech, declaring her retirement once again. “There’s no way I could have ended it better than this,” she said. “I want to have some more babies, and I’ve got to get cooking.”

The announcement marked the end of an era—not just for Rousey, but for the sport. Her 2015 loss to Holm was a cultural moment, proving that even legends could be defeated. Yet her return, and the ease with which she dominated Carano, reinforced her status as an all-time great.

Beyond the Controversy: What the Fight Really Proved

The backlash against Rousey’s victory, while loud, was predictable. MMA has a history of skepticism toward women’s combat sports, often dismissing achievements as “easy wins” or “rigged.” But the data tells a different story:

Beyond the Controversy: What the Fight Really Proved
Former Teammate Shayna Baszler Women
  • Rousey holds the record for the most finishes by armbar in UFC history (12).
  • Her 2015 loss to Holm was the first—and only—time she was submitted in her UFC career.
  • Post-fight analysis by Bloody Elbow confirmed that Carano’s escape attempt was unsuccessful, as Rousey maintained control throughout.

For Baszler, the fight was less about controversy and more about legacy. “Ronda’s armbar isn’t just a technique—it’s an institution,” she told reporters. “And institutions don’t get dismantled in 17 seconds.”