Andrew Patterson’s second feature, The Rivals of Amziah King, opens in Italian theaters Thursday after a two-year festival journey that began at Sundance, according to Libero.
The film marks Matthew McConaughey’s return to independent cinema, pairing him with Kurt Russell in rural Oklahoma.
Patterson, whose debut The Vast of Night arrived with micro-budget sci-fi precision, shifts here to a genre hybrid that has split Italian critics between enthusiasm and charges of confusion.
“It is no coincidence that The Ballad of the Bee King has so far split criticism, between those who welcomed Andrew Patterson’s new work with enthusiasm and those who judged it a confused work,” Libero.it wrote.

Cinematografo.it described a film that “changes skin and perspective” midstream, moving from communal portrait to crime thriller when rivals steal Amziah’s hives. MoviePlayer.it called the screenplay “literally unpredictable, vibrating like a splendid and melancholy bluegrass ballad,” while noting a 131-minute runtime that “maybe [is] a little too much.”
McConaughey plays Amziah King, a charismatic beekeeper-musician who fosters troubled teens in a trailer-park community bound by bluegrass. When he reconnects with Kateri (Angelina LookingGlass), the Native American daughter he once fostered, the film spends its first half on apprenticeship — honey harvests, mandolin sessions, the hive as metaphor for collective survival. The film is set in rural Oklahoma, where Amziah’s community lives in a trailer park and gathers for evenings of music and shared hardship. Libero.it described the first half as centered on Kateri’s initiation into beekeeping and the honey trade, with the hive serving as a metaphor for a community where everyone helps each other.
Then the hives are stolen. The tone pivots to revenge thriller, centering Kateri’s investigation and Russell’s antagonist. Libero.it argued the shift “risks disorienting the viewer,” leaving the father-daughter reconstruction “only sketched.” Cinematografo.it framed the turn as “the most courageous story of Patterson,” a deliberate “passing of the torch” between genres.
MoviePlayer.it likened the result to “a dysfunctional gangster movie, a coming-of-age and… a kind of modern western.” The theft triggers a darker, faster second half in which Kateri investigates the crime and undergoes a sharp character transformation.
Debut performance anchors the pivot
LookingGlass, in her feature debut, draws particular praise. Cinematografo.it called her “a revelation”; MoviePlayer.it said she “holds the screen” opposite McConaughey.

Oklahoma light and a bluegrass score
Miguel I. Littin-Menz’s cinematography bathes the Oklahoma locations in “hot and raw” light, per MoviePlayer.it. The soundtrack blends existing tracks — The Avett Brothers’ “Talk on Indolence,” performed by McConaughey and Seth Avett — with original pieces like “Quill” by Ben Hardesty, according to Cinematografo. Cinematografo.it noted the music “is not simple interlude, but contributes to defining the character of Amziah.”
From suspended tension to choral storytelling
Patterson told Cinematografo.it the film widens the horizon from The Vast of Night‘s suspended tension toward “coralità” — choral storytelling — and a meditation on family and belonging. After The Vast of Night, Patterson expands his poetics, leaving the territory of unease and science fiction to immerse himself in the rural soul of Oklahoma. The comparison with The Vast of Night highlights the director’s path.
Andrew Patterson, born in 1982, began his film career as a high-school projectionist before founding a production company, GED Media, in Oklahoma City that made commercials and promotional shorts for the Oklahoma City Thunder.
He self-financed his debut, The Vast of Night, writing under the pseudonym James Montague, and endured rejections from 18 festivals before it premiered at Slamdance in 2019, where it won the Best Narrative Feature Audience Award and was later acquired by Amazon Studios. Patterson lives in Oklahoma.
Italian release date: November 19. Runtime: 131 minutes.
Keep reading