Michael Atherton said Pat Cummins faces no immediate threat to the Australia Test captaincy despite Cameron Bancroft’s explosive Sandpapergate statement, Sky Sports reported.
The former England captain told the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast that Cricket Australia’s public backing and Cummins’ on-field record insulate him for now, though he warned a shift in public sympathy toward Bancroft could change the equation.
“I don’t think so, yet,” Atherton said when asked if Cummins’ position was untenable. “A few things are obvious. One, he has the support of Cricket Australia. David Boone, about a week ago, was very clear about that. On Wednesday, Boone and Todd Greenberg reiterated that very strongly.”
Cricket Australia backs captain amid Bancroft allegations
Cummins dismissed Usman Khawaja’s claims on Nov. 13, calling them “100 per cent wrong” during a press conference. Bancroft responded with a 4,000-word statement supporting Khawaja’s account, writing that Cummins’ denials left him “angry, betrayed and alone,” according to thisisthecoast.co.uk.
Cummins’ management subsequently issued statements asserting there was “nothing in the [Bancroft’s] statement that hasn’t been answered” and that the captain had been “consistent and adamant” from day one, gigantum.net reported.
Boone, Cricket Australia’s interim chair, and Greenberg, the chief executive, have publicly reinforced their support for Cummins in recent days. Atherton noted the captain holds significant “credit in the bank” for transforming the team culture and keeping Australia “at the top of the tree.”
Public reaction could alter Calculus
Atherton identified public sentiment as the variable that could destabilize Cummins’ position. He described the fast bowler as the “blue-eyed boy of Australian cricket” but said sympathy is shifting toward the players who served bans in 2018.
“But the public reaction will be interesting because the sympathy now is almost going towards the lads who took the fall, particularly Bancroft,” Atherton said.
“If the sympathy moves that way, it’ll move against the others who are in the other camp, of which Cummins is one. That public reaction will be interesting. It will probably be important.”
He added that organizations are “pretty fickle” and support can evaporate if the public turns. “I don’t know what he said today, but they, the cameras, were chasing him today. It’s very much that kind of febrile atmosphere at the moment.”
Bancroft details wider ball-tampering culture
Bancroft’s statement alleged sandpaper was used in the second Test at Port Elizabeth as well as the third Test at Cape Town, according to thisisthecoast.co.uk. He recalled conversations with Australia’s pace group — Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh — about “whether it was swinging enough,” and said all players and coaches were present when media manager Kate Hutchinson expressed opposition to the plans.
“There is still some doubt about exactly who knew what,” Atherton said.
“It seems to me that two things are absolutely clear. One is the build-up to it. And I’ve read Usman Khawaja’s book, Sabr. It’s a very interesting book in a broader sense than just the sandpaper stuff. But reading his book, reading what Cameron Bancroft said in that 4,000-word statement, it’s clear that [there was in] the build-up to the South Africa tour, this almost institutional pressure that was put on the team, this win-at-all-costs mentality, is how they phrased it.”
Atherton noted Greenberg has acknowledged Cricket Australia bore accountability for that environment. “It was a build-up of pressure. And that was the dressing room that Cameron Bancroft walked into.”
Pat Cummins, born in 1993, made his Test debut against South Africa in 2011 as the youngest Australian Test cricketer since 1953, claiming six wickets in the second innings. He did not play another Test until 2017, six years after his debut, before establishing himself as the world’s leading fast bowler and ascending to the captaincy in November 2021.
Khawaja claims team knew of tampering; Bancroft backs account
Usman Khawaja made claims in his book Sabr that the entire Australian team knew about ball tampering during the 2018 South Africa tour. Cameron Bancroft subsequently issued a 4,000-word statement supporting Khawaja’s account, contradicting Pat Cummins’ denials.
No. Interim chair David Boone and chief executive Todd Greenberg have publicly reiterated their support for Cummins as Test captain in the past week.
Bancroft claimed sandpaper was also used during the second Test at Port Elizabeth, not only the third Test at Cape Town where he was caught on camera.
Could Cummins still lose the captaincy? Atherton said there is no “immediate threat” but warned that a sustained shift in public sympathy toward Bancroft could pressure Cricket Australia to reconsider its stance.
Related reading