Delaware would bar all but the largest public companies from hosting precatory stockholder proposals under a draft statute released Monday, a move that would take effect only if the SEC rescinds its long-standing Rule 14a-8.
The Council of the Corporation Law Section of the Delaware State Bar Association published the white paper and discussion draft on Nov. 9, proposing a new Section 214 of the Delaware General Corporation Law. The statute would create a tiered “basket” allowing one to three non-binding proposals at companies valued at $30 billion or more, while eliminating the mechanism entirely for smaller listed corporations, JD Supra reported.
The proposal responds directly to the SEC’s Sept. 16 plan to rescind Rule 14a-8, which has governed shareholder proposals for roughly 80 years, according to Richards, Layton & Finger. The Commission indicated it expected states to adopt their own standards for proxy inclusion as a matter of state corporate law.
Tiered caps based on market value
Draft Section 214 would permit precatory proposals only at listed Delaware corporations with a market capitalization of at least $30 billion, measured ten days before the record date for the prior year’s annual meeting, Davis Polk noted. The caps are structured in three tiers:
| Tier | Market capitalization | Maximum proposals per annual meeting |
|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | $100 billion or more | Three |
| Tier 2 | $50 billion to $100 billion | Two |
| Tier 3 | $30 billion to $50 billion | One |
Listed companies below $30 billion and non-listed companies would not be subject to stockholder-submitted precatory proposals at all, Ropes & Gray reported. If more qualifying proposals are submitted than the cap allows, the three largest proponent groups by voting-stock ownership would fill the slots; later withdrawal of a selected proposal would not reopen the slot.
Higher ownership thresholds, stricter procedural rules
A proponent must beneficially own at least $250,000 of voting stock individually, or $1 million together with up to nine co-filers, with shares held continuously for 365 days ending on the 30th day before the submission deadline. That compares with the current Rule 14a-8 thresholds of $2,000 to $25,000 depending on holding period, Davis Polk noted.
Proposals and supporting statements together may not exceed 500 words and must be received no later than 180 days before the anniversary of the prior annual meeting. The corporation must notify proponents of procedural deficiencies within 14 days, and the proponent then has 14 days to cure — with no further cure opportunity, JD Supra reported.
Narrower exclusion grounds than Rule 14a-8
The draft lists 12 specific bases for exclusion, omitting Rule 14a-8’s subjective “ordinary business” exclusion. A proposal could be excluded if it expressly questions the character of director nominees, primarily seeks to redress a personal grievance, seeks to circumvent the statute, or if the proponent is a director, officer, or controlled by one.
The white paper states the Council aimed for a “largely objective” framework to minimize litigation between companies and proponents, according to JD Supra.
Resubmission would be barred for a proponent whose proposal received less than 15% of votes cast at either of the two preceding annual meetings — a shift from Rule 14a-8, which bars resubmission of substantially similar proposals based on prior vote totals, Davis Polk noted.
Section 214 creates exclusive path for precatory proposals
Section 214 would be the exclusive means for stockholders to present a precatory proposal; proposals outside the basket could not be voted on even if the proponent solicited proxies at its own expense. Certificates of incorporation and bylaws could neither add to nor reduce the statutory requirements, though the board could voluntarily submit any precatory proposal, JD Supra reported.
Newly public companies receive a five-year grace period from initial listing.
Disputes would be resolved in the Delaware Court of Chancery. A proponent may challenge an exclusion within 30 days of the corporation’s determination notice, and the corporation bears the burden of proving the exclusion was proper, according to Richards, Layton & Finger.
Legislative timeline targets 2028 proxy season
The white paper has not yet been approved by the DSBA or the Corporation Law Section.
The Delaware State Bar Association, founded in 1923 as a voluntary organization, counts roughly 90% of the state’s private-practice attorneys among its members. Its Corporation Law Section, with more than 500 attorneys, judges and academics, formulates and recommends amendments to the Delaware General Corporation Law and related statutes after approval by the full association.
For the 2027 proxy season, Rule 14a-8 would likely remain in effect, though companies would need to handle exclusion determinations without SEC staff review, the white paper noted.
Keep reading