International Edition
Latest News
Sport

CBF withholds VAR analysis of Barboza penalty

Palmeiras defends first-leg lead against Vasco in Copa do Brasil The Palmeiras football squad holds a 1-0 advantage over Vasco entering the return leg of the Copa do Brasil semifinals following a tightly contested opening match at Nubank…

CBF withholds VAR analysis of Barboza penalty

Palmeiras defends first-leg lead against Vasco in Copa do Brasil

The Palmeiras football squad holds a 1-0 advantage over Vasco entering the return leg of the Copa do Brasil semifinals following a tightly contested opening match at Nubank Parque in São Paulo. Maurício secured the decisive goal for Palmeiras, giving the team the cushion of needing only a draw in the upcoming fixture at São Januário to advance to the tournament final. The match outcome triggered extensive fallout regarding match officiating, tactical approaches, and disciplinary actions across both clubs.

Controversial Officiating Decisions and Institutional Friction

Match referee Anderson Daronco faced sharp criticism from Vasco leadership following the final whistle. Vasco director of football Admar Lopes characterized the officiating performance as “vergonhosa”, pointing to a penalty non-call in the second half when Alan Lescano attempted to dribble Alexander Barboza and the ball struck defender Alexander Barboza’s arm inside the penalty box at the 4th minute of the second half. Vasco president Pedrinho confronted Daronco directly in the stadium tunnel after the match to contest the ruling. Additional friction stemmed from the first-half booking and subsequent non-expulsion arguments regarding Saldivia, specifically citing that Daronco did not intervene on the second yellow and expulsion of Saldivia, alongside a first-minute challenge where Colidio suffered a foul by Murilo while initiating a counter-attack without receiving a yellow card, contrasting with the caution given to Saldivia after a push on Jhon Arias in midfield.

CBF Withholds VAR Review Analysis

The Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) will not release the analysis of the VAR regarding the possible penalty by Barboza.

Social Media Reaction and Tactical Disclosures

Palmeiras midfielder Lucas Evangelista generated widespread attention during the match when television cameras captured him raising his arm in apparent agreement with Vasco penalty appeals. Defender Bruno Fuchs also joined the online interaction, joking that Evangelista’s reaction resulted from a blow he took to the face during the first half. Meanwhile, Palmeiras manager Abel Ferreira delivered a pointed post-match critique regarding his disciplinary suspensions on Sunday, 1º. Ferreira questioned whether authorities intend to use him as a “Cristo” due to the unprecedented nature of his suspensions for touchline behavior, and confirmed he will no longer comment on referees after stating that no other coach has received matches of suspension like he has. Abel also noted that conditioning factors like distance between matches, lack of uniformity, and resuming tournaments without intervals after the FIFA date impact championships, while defending the club’s artificial pitch against poor natural surfaces and predicting a duel with “sofrimento” since he noted that since his arrival the team has never reached this stage in all competitions simultaneously.

CBF withholds VAR analysis of Barboza penalty
Photo: UOL

Frequently Asked Questions About the Match

What does Palmeiras need to do to reach the Copa do Brasil final?

Following their 1-0 victory at Nubank Parque courtesy of Maurício’s goal, Palmeiras can advance with either a win or a draw in the away fixture.

CBF withholds VAR analysis of Barboza penalty
Photo: Gazeta Esportiva

What specific refereeing incidents drew complaints from Vasco?

Vasco directors contested a first-minute challenge on Colidio by Murilo that did not yield a yellow card, the failure of the VAR to intervene on the second yellow and expulsion of Saldivia and on the penalty appeal for a handball by Barboza against Lescano at the 4th minute of the second half, and the overall handling of disciplinary cards by referee Anderson Daronco.

Penalty Given… But VAR Missed a RED? | Referee’s Eye Analysis #02
About the author: Javier Moreno - Sports Editor

Former sideline reporter and FIFA‑accredited correspondent. Javier covers football, boxing, and Olympic sports, blending analytics with athlete‑focused storytelling. Javier Moreno offers in‑depth sports coverage, live analysis, and exclusive interviews from global arenas.