A new peer-reviewed study examining mortality risks among Florida residents following their first round of COVID-19 vaccination has been misrepresented online by state health officials and commentators, according to vaccine experts who say the data does not establish that the Pfizer vaccine was dangerous or caused deaths, FactCheck.org reported.
The study, published Nov. 4 in the journal Global Epidemiology, was mostly conducted by members of the Florida Department of Health using state data. It matched nearly one million adult recipients of Pfizer’s mRNA vaccine with an equal number who received the Moderna shot, based on seven criteria including age, sex, race, and ethnicity.
Within one year following the initial dose, adults who got the Pfizer vaccine exhibited a 40% higher all-cause mortality risk in comparison to individuals administered the Moderna option. Compared with Moderna, the Pfizer immunization additionally correlated with a 91% increased likelihood of death from COVID-19, a 57% greater risk of cardiovascular mortality, and a 37% elevated risk of non-COVID-19 death as documented on death certificates.
Despite the study not comparing outcomes to unvaccinated people, Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo published social media commentary on November 5, 2026, warning about mRNA shots based on the paper he co-authored. Ladapo amplified a message from vaccine skeptic Retsef Levi, whom U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. previously tried to appoint to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices.

“As I said in January 2024, no one should be taking mRNA COVID-19 vaccines because of their terrible safety profile,” Dr. Joseph Ladapo wrote on X the day after publication. “But for those who had to take one, Florida’s public health data strongly implies that thousands of Floridians died as a result of receiving Pfizer instead of Moderna. The number of lives lost in the U.S. and internationally is staggering, based on this analysis.”
Florida remains the only U.S. state that advises against mRNA COVID-19 vaccines.
Speaking to Children’s Health Defense, Ladapo framed the results as indicative of a safety concern, saying the new study helps show that “our system for evaluating vaccine safety is broken.” He added, “The findings of this study should not be interpreted as establishing the overall safety of the Moderna vaccine,” and stated, “We reiterate our recommendation that, based on what is currently known about the safety of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, no one should receive them.” The Florida Department of Health did not respond to inquiries asking about his interpretation of the study and whether the department shared his views.
Critical assessment of what we can and cannot conclude from the new Levi/Ladapo Pfizer vs. Moderna Florida all-cause death study https://t.co/7IMgpMuJeU
Online figures amplified the narrative. Former tech entrepreneur Steve Kirsch wrote, “This is an extremely important paper. It shows that the Pfizer vaccine was not safe. It killed people. There is no other way to interpret this data.”
However, independent experts cautioned that such interpretations go far beyond what the research shows.
Jeffrey S. Morris, the director of biostatistics at the University of Pennsylvania, wrote on X that Ladapo’s comment “is like orders of magnitude beyond what his own paper showed.” Morris said that even if the mortality difference were entirely causal, it could reflect Moderna providing greater protection against COVID-19 and its complications rather than Pfizer causing direct vaccine toxicity.
Born in Nigeria on December 16, 1978, Joseph Abiodun Ladapo immigrated to the United States as a child. He graduated from Wake Forest University in 2000, where he competed as a varsity track athlete, before earning an M.D. and a Ph.D. in health policy from Harvard University in 2008.
Prior to being appointed surgeon general of Florida in 2021 by Governor Ron DeSantis, Ladapo worked as a professor of medicine at New York University and received tenure at the University of California, Los Angeles.
Natalie Dean, an associate professor of biostatistics at Emory University, stated, “A difference between two groups does not mean harm,” adding that it would be a big leap to attribute higher all-cause mortality in the Pfizer group to the vaccine being dangerous. An independent group of scientists at Unbiased Science similarly concluded that anyone claiming certainty in either direction is going further than the data supports.
Worth a look