International Edition
Latest News
Health

Federal Lawsuit Over Doctor Age-Based Testing Heads to Trial

Age-based fitness testing for doctors triggered a federal discrimination lawsuit that now heads toward trial after a judge denied opposing dismissal motions on October 23, ACSH reported. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued Yale New Haven Hospital in…

Federal Lawsuit Over Doctor Age-Based Testing Heads to Trial

Age-based fitness testing for doctors triggered a federal discrimination lawsuit that now heads toward trial after a judge denied opposing dismissal motions on October 23, ACSH reported.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued Yale New Haven Hospital in 2020 over a policy requiring practitioners aged 70 and older to pass eye and neuropsychological exams to maintain hospital privileges. The program tested 145 individuals by April 2019, with only 80 achieving an unqualified passing grade, according to ACSH.

“Research shows that the average cognitive ability declines by more than 20% …. in those between ages 40 and 75 years, but there is significant variability from one person to another, indicating that while some older physicians are profoundly impaired, others retain their ability and skills,” ACSH reported.

Roughly two dozen health systems across 14 states enforce age-based medical screenings triggered at age 70 or 75, ACSH reported. Roughly 80 percent of these 29 programs require biannual reassessments, while nearly 90 percent mandate physical examinations.

Five physicians targeted by Yale resigned before taking the exams, fearing adverse results, according to ACSH. One study cited in the report showed that more than 25 percent of those targeted for re-examination resigned prior to screening, claiming “that the process [is]… intrusive, stigmatizing, or potentially unfair.”

“Cognitive aging is heterogeneous [and] many clinicians retain or deepen clinically relevant capacities while others develop cognitive, medical, or sensory impairments that raise justifiable safety concerns,” said James Ellisoon, co-director of the Comprehensive Alzheimer’s Center, Jefferson Health, as reported by ACSH.

Federal law prohibits treating job applicants and employees differently based on age under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Exceptions exist for public safety roles, such as a mandatory retirement age of 56 for air-traffic controllers.

Judicial retention standards differ significantly between state and federal courts. Thirty-two states require judges to retire between ages 70 and 75, a practice the Supreme Court approved in 1991. Federal judges have a constitutionally protected right to serve for life, though physical and mental fitness disputes still emerge in federal courts.

“There is probable cause to believe that Judge Newman’s health has left her without the capacity to perform the work of an active judge and that her habitual delays are prejudicial to the efficient administration of justice,” a court ruled regarding 96-year-old Judge Pauline Newman of the 12th Circuit, as reported by ACSH.

Physicians aged 70 and older must undergo eye and neuropsychological examinations to renew their medical staff privileges, according to the hospital policy reviewed by ACSH.

Roughly two dozen health systems across 14 states enforce age-based screenings triggered at ages 70 or 75, ACSH reported.

On October 23, the court denied the motions for an immediate ruling, and the case now proceeds to trial, according to ACSH.

About the author: Health Desk

Health Desk at Archynewsy.