International Edition
Latest News
News

GOP Candidate Sues to Discard Ballots Weeks After Ohio Election

"Simply put, Schimmel seeks to change the rules of the game after it has already been played," David Fournier told Democracy Docket. Republican state House candidate Edward Schimmel sued the Lucas County Board of Elections in the Ohio…

Voters cast their ballots inside a polling location on Nov. 3 in Youngstown, Ohio. (Photo: Jeff Swensen/Getty Images)

“Simply put, Schimmel seeks to change the rules of the game after it has already been played,” David Fournier told Democracy Docket.

Republican state House candidate Edward Schimmel sued the Lucas County Board of Elections in the Ohio Supreme Court nearly two weeks after the midterm elections to discard provisional ballots cast by voters who recently moved within the state. Schimmel led his Democratic opponent, Fournier, by only 33 votes as of noon Thursday.

The legal challenge targets voters who relocated to Lucas County from another Ohio county but failed to update their registration addresses before the Nov. 3 midterm elections, according to Democracy Docket.

Ohio election law allows such voters to cast provisional ballots at their new polling locations, which election officials verify and count later. Schimmel argues that those voters should have cast provisional ballots directly at a board of elections office rather than at local polling places.

1,100 Provisional Ballots Could Flip This Ohio House Race #shorts — WHIO

The lawsuit claims that guidance issued in August by Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose violated state law by telling local officials that out-of-county movers could use polling locations to cast provisional ballots. Matt Kelly of the Ohio House Republican Organizational Committee said that the committee wants to ensure that every legally cast vote is counted in tight northwest Ohio races, 13abc reported.

Lucas County contains Toledo, Ohio’s fourth-most-populous city. The Lucas County Board of Elections asked the state supreme court to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that the claims are moot because the board already verified, accepted, and counted provisional ballots during a special session on Monday.

GOP Candidate Sues to Discard Ballots Weeks After Ohio Election
Photo: demdock.com

Intervention and Legal Arguments

Fournier filed a motion to intervene in the case on Wednesday, accompanied by a motion to dismiss. He criticized Schimmel for waiting until weeks after the election to challenge guidance that was published months earlier.

Civil rights groups entered the legal battle Wednesday as well. The Ohio branches of the League of Women Voters and the American Civil Liberties Union filed an amicus brief warning that invalidating the challenged ballots would disenfranchise voters through no fault of their own. “[Schimmel] asks the Court to prohibit the Board of Elections from counting ballots cast on Election Day with no opportunity for voters to cure their ballots,” the groups wrote in their brief, as cited by Democracy Docket. “The inevitable result—indeed, the intended result—is disenfranchisement.”

Ohio House Republican committee challenges ballots in Wood, Lucas counties — WTVG 13 Action News | Toledo, OH

Frequently Asked Questions

How many provisional ballots were accepted by Lucas County?

The Lucas County Board of Elections accepted 2,375 provisional ballots and rejected 350 others during a special session held on Monday, according to Democracy Docket.

Which other Ohio county recently certified its legislative results?

The Wood County Board of Elections certified Rick Rettig as the winner of the state House race in District 75 on Wednesday morning, 13abc reported.

Frank LaRose, a Republican, has served as Ohio’s 51st secretary of state since January 2019. Before that, he spent eight years in the Ohio State Senate, where he chaired the State and Local Government Committee and sponsored legislation that eliminated the state’s “golden week” of same-day registration and voting in 2014.

LaRose also authored the 2016 law that introduced online voter registration in Ohio. Earlier, he served in the U.S. Army Special Forces as a Green Beret, earning a Bronze Star for his service in Iraq.

GOP Candidate Sues to Discard Ballots Weeks After Ohio Election
Photo: 13abc.com

What law firm is representing Edward Schimmel in the litigation?

The law firm Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP represents Schimmel and sent multiple county boards letters demanding that they set aside ballots cast by recent movers, Democracy Docket reported.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.