International Edition
Latest News
News

Health Minister to Miss CUH Meeting as Taoiseach Attends

Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill will not attend Monday’s meeting between Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Cork University Hospital leadership, her office confirmed Sunday, after days of ambiguity over whether she would join the talks prompted by months of…

Health Minister to Miss CUH Meeting as Taoiseach Attends

Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill will not attend Monday’s meeting between Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Cork University Hospital leadership, her office confirmed Sunday, after days of ambiguity over whether she would join the talks prompted by months of patient-safety warnings from the hospital’s chief executive, RTÉ reported.

The meeting, scheduled for Monday, will bring Martin, CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney and HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor together at the hospital in Martin’s Cork South-Central constituency.

A spokesperson for Carroll MacNeill initially declined to confirm her attendance, then clarified two hours later: “He’s going in his capacity as a TD for Cork South Central. She’s not going with him, they are in close contact on this.”

Opposition: Taoiseach cannot shed role for local visit

Social Democrats health spokesperson Pádraig Rice, who also chairs the Oireachtas health committee and represents Cork South-Central, called the distinction “nonsense.” “Is he going to walk through some door and suddenly not become the Taoiseach? This is the kind of nonsense we’re dealing with,” Rice told The Week in Politics. He said Carroll MacNeill’s absence would be “unacceptable” and accused her of being “very quiet” on the crisis.

Sinn Féin social protection spokesperson Louise O’Reilly echoed the criticism. “I don’t know how the switcheroo goes when the Taoiseach is the Taoiseach one minute, and then he’s just a TD the next,” O’Reilly said on the same programme.

She added it was “extraordinary” the minister had not met Kearney, including during the Fine Gael ard fheis in Cork two weeks ago when she was “less than 2km down the road.”

Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill. Photograph: Alan Betson/The Irish Times
Photo: The Irish Times

HSE says safety assessment ‘broadly reassuring’

The Department of Health said the National Patient Safety Office and HSE chief clinical officer Dr Colm Henry had reviewed CUH’s concerns and found the safety assessment “broadly reassuring, notwithstanding ongoing pressures associated with increased demand.” Carroll MacNeill’s office said she welcomed a forthcoming independent assessment by HIQA of the hospital’s management of emergency-department pressure.

HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor told the Oireachtas health committee Wednesday that CUH was “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity.” She said pressures at CUH were not unique and that the hospital’s staffing increase this year exceeded the combined increases at Beaumont, the Mater, St James’s and Tallaght University hospitals.

Kearney wrote to the government in August warning CUH would not be safe entering winter with a shortfall of about 1,000 staff. She sought urgent approval for 172 priority posts and staffing for 21 acute beds. Rice said there had been an “effort to discredit” Kearney over the past week. “We heard on the radio last Sunday, we saw it at the health committee during the week, and I think it is not acceptable,” he said. “We have to create a culture in the health service where clinical leaders feel free to speak up when they see foreseeable patient safety risks, and that is what Jennifer Kearney did,” he said.

“I think that’s commendable, I think it’s brave, I think we need more people within the health service who are going to speak up, and we have to have a culture where that is allowed, where that’s encouraged, and where that’s supported.”

Fine Gael junior minister John Cummins defended the government’s record, citing a “significant staff increase” and higher funding.

“We’re not asking people to do more with less, we’re asking people to do more with more,” he said, though he acknowledged he did not know if Carroll MacNeill would attend Monday’s meeting.

Rice said Cork University Hospital is “under extraordinary pressure”. He said: “We’ve seen a 12% increase in the admissions at the emergency department, we have two CT scanners that are operating at 50% capacity, and we have pressures right across the board.”

Health Minister to Miss CUH Meeting as Taoiseach Attends
Photo: The Journal

Patients describe corridor waits, praise staff

Patients outside CUH’s emergency department this week described long trolley waits and corridor care but uniformly praised staff. Philomena Molloy, a cancer patient from Carrigaline, said she spent a night on a chair and was placed in a leukaemia ward because no lymphoma bed was available. “The staff are lovely, I can’t fault them, but what’s happening is shocking,” she told the Irish Examiner.

Her son said one nurse “even snatched a teabag from the nurses’ staffroom for her because she loves her green tea”. Another patient’s daughter said her 76-year-old father lay on a trolley in “absolute agony for eight hours before he saw a doctor.” Terri Hayes, from Youghal, is 80.

Rice cited a 12% rise in emergency admissions and CT scanners operating at 50% capacity.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.