International Edition
Latest News
News

In the First Weeks of a Record-Breaking El Niño

In the first weeks of a record-breaking El Niño, tidal flooding and wave-shattered boardwalks have laid bare the futility of trying to hold back the rising sea, while a voluntary buyout program that passed the Legislature unanimously sits…

In the First Weeks of a Record-Breaking El Niño

In the first weeks of a record-breaking El Niño, tidal flooding and wave-shattered boardwalks have laid bare the futility of trying to hold back the rising sea, while a voluntary buyout program that passed the Legislature unanimously sits dead after two gubernatorial vetoes.

Sen. Ben Allen (D-Santa Monica) introduced Senate Bill 83 in 2021 to let the state buy vulnerable beachfront homes at fair-market value, rent them back to owners, and eventually demolish the structures to restore natural buffers. The bill cleared every committee and passed the Senate 33-2 with no registered opposition, Los Angeles Times reported. Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed it, saying the measure did not comprehensively address its multi-decade cost. Allen reintroduced a refined version as Senate Bill 1078 in 2022 with backing from then-Controller Betty Yee and Humboldt County officials. Newsom vetoed that bill, too.

“What was great about this proposal is still great about this proposal,” said A.R. Siders, a relocation expert at the University of Delaware’s Disaster Research Center. “It’s low risk, too: It sounds expensive, but the cost of buying a few properties is not that high in the grand scheme of how much money we pour into disaster response.”

Legislative analysts warned in 2019 that $8 billion to $10 billion in coastal property could be underwater by 2050, with another $6 billion to $10 billion at risk during high tides. The National Institute of Building Sciences estimates society saves at least $6 in avoided disaster costs for every $1 spent acquiring or removing flood-prone buildings beforehand. Seawalls remain the default emergency response, but they drown the beach in front of them. Sand replenishment requires endless upkeep.

Managed retreat — moving people and infrastructure inland — is often the most cost-effective long-term option, yet political resistance has made it a nonstarter. In Pacifica, the 2016 El Niño left apartment buildings teetering on cliffs. The city spent $16 million on emergency response that year — nearly half its $36 million operating budget. An eminent-domain battle dragged on for years, and the public absorbed the cost. John Keener said a buy-and-rent program would have put the city years ahead. “If that program had passed … some of these properties would have probably been halfway paid for by now,” he said. “What happened instead was … nothing.”

A UC Santa Barbara graduate study recently modeled the approach for Pacifica, Carpinteria and Stinson Beach and found it financially feasible.

Charles Lester, director of the campus Ocean and Coastal Policy Center, said without a planned retreat mechanism, communities default to “ad hoc boulders piled up on beaches” and homeowners left to deal with disaster aftermath alone.

“The problem is only going to intensify and this would help people move in a non-catastrophic, non-traumatic way before the disaster hits,” said Julia Stein, deputy director of UCLA’s Emmett Institute on Climate Change and the Environment, who helped develop the proposal.

Allen, who is completing his final Senate term, told lawmakers in 2021: “Think about the cost and lives that could’ve been saved if California had taken more action decades ago to better mitigate against the threat of today’s wildfires.”

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.