Actress Jiřina Bohdalová remains in a decade-long legal struggle to recover a painting attributed to Emil Filla, Still Life with Pipe and Grapes, which was seized by police as part of a high-profile forgery investigation. While an appellate court recently upheld the convictions of three art dealers involved in the fraud, the painting remains held as evidence, leaving the actress without the work she purchased for 1,5 milionu korun.
Appellate Court Upholds Sentences for Art Fraud
The Prague High Court recently concluded that the lower court’s decision was sufficiently justified, affirming the convictions of Jaroslav Fröhlich, his wife Eva Fröhlichová, and Milan Trokan. The appellate senate found the sentencing appropriate, noting that the court correctly distinguished the level of involvement for each participant. Prosecutors established that the group generated millions in damages by creating counterfeit pieces and providing them with forged expert assessments. The court ordered the trio to pay damages to the victims, with the total financial impact of the fraud exceeding 25 milionů korun, alongside additional attempted scams totaling 36,5 milionů korun. The appellate court took up the case for a second time after an earlier verdict was overturned by the High Court in a closed session.
The Origins of the Fake Art Ring
The investigation into the fraud began in 2017 at the Regional Court in Prague. Evidence presented in court revealed that the group operated through a network of galleries and private contacts. The defendants utilized Radek Pokluda, a private banker at Komerční banka, to sell the forged pieces to high-profile clients, including director Ivan Zachariáš and Radio Impuls CEO Jiří Hrabák. Pokluda reportedly misled buyers by claiming the paintings were repossessed bank assets. Police eventually dropped the case against the banker, concluding he was unaware he was facilitating the sale of forgeries. The defendants claimed ownership of large art collections and staged fake auctions to drive up prices, which went from tens of thousands to millions of korun.
Bohdalová’s Ongoing Effort to Reclaim Her Property
Despite the criminal convictions, the status of the paintings remains a point of contention. While Bohdalová successfully recovered two paintings identified as fakes from the police, the most expensive piece, the Filla Still Life with Pipe and Grapes, has not been returned. The actress has faced conflicting expert opinions regarding the work’s authenticity, with two reports identifying it as an original while a third remained inconclusive. The legal impasse has persisted for years, with the Constitutional Court previously rejecting an appeal from Bohdalová to release the work. The court maintained that the painting remains a necessary piece of evidence for ongoing legal proceedings. During a recent court appearance on November 3, the actress expressed her frustration with the slow pace of the judicial process, noting that she has little time left to wait for a resolution. They probably thought I would die during that time, but I got them through,
she quipped at the hearing. She added, And if it doesn’t work out, I won’t give up, okay?
Sentencing and Restitution
The Regional Court imposed significant prison terms, sentencing Jaroslav Fröhlich to six and a half years, while Eva Fröhlichová and Milan Trokan received five and six years respectively. The court imposed a 600,000-korun fine on Trokan and the wife, while Fröhlich received a ten-million-korun penalty. Despite the court awarding Bohdalová the 1,5 milionu korun in restitution, the physical return of the painting remains blocked by its status as evidence.
Court Justifies Evidence Retention for Stolen Artwork
Why has the court not returned the painting to Jiřina Bohdalová?
The court has ruled that the painting must remain in police custody because it is considered essential evidence for the ongoing criminal case. Despite the convictions of the art dealers, the work is still subject to legal requirements regarding the preservation of evidence.
What was the total damage caused by the convicted art dealers?
According to the court’s findings, the trio caused damages exceeding 25 milionů korun and attempted further fraudulent transactions totaling 36,5 milionů korun. The court has ordered the defendants to compensate the victims for these losses.
What is the current status of the legal proceedings?
While the appellate court has confirmed the convictions and sentences for the three defendants, the case remains active regarding the final disposition of the seized property. Bohdalová continues to seek the return of the painting, which she purchased for 1,5 milionu korun, but the timeline for its release remains uncertain.
Related reading