Detroit Tigers’ Pitching Conundrum: Montero’s Case for a Starting Role as Verlander Returns

The Detroit Tigers face a strategic dilemma as Justin Verlander nears a return from injury, potentially leaving manager A.J. Hinch with a surplus of starting pitchers, according to sources familiar with the team’s plans.

What’s the current state of the Tigers’ pitching rotation?

Verlander’s recent rehab start with Triple-A Toledo has reignited discussions about the Tigers’ rotation depth. With seven potential starters—including Verlander, Matt Manning, and Daniel Montero—Hinch acknowledged the challenge of balancing the roster. “There’s a lot of names and a lot of quality pitchers in that mix,” Hinch said, emphasizing the team’s focus on deploying its best talent.

Even if the Tigers adopt a six-man rotation, surplus pitchers may need to transition to the bullpen. Montero, who has started 10 games this season, is positioning himself as a strong candidate for a starting role despite not matching the hype of prospects like Tarik Skubal or Casey Mize.

How has Daniel Montero performed this season?

Montero’s 3.61 ERA and 1.01 WHIP through 10 starts have been bolstered by his ability to limit damage. In a recent start against the Twins, he allowed just four singles and a walk, holding Minnesota to a 84.5 mph average exit velocity. His pitch mix has evolved significantly: whereas his slider and four-seamer were negative in 2022, his four-seamer and changeup now carry positive run values, according to Statcast.

“He’s becoming a more well-rounded pitcher,” Hinch said. “He’s got two shapes of breaking balls. He’s getting more confident with the change.” Montero’s focus on attacking all parts of the strike zone has led to his fifth start this season of six or more innings with one run or fewer.

Why is Montero’s role critical to the Tigers’ success?

Montero’s steady performance has made him a fan favorite, both in Detroit and during his World Baseball Classic run with Venezuela. Despite lacking the high-profile pedigree of Verlander or Framber Valdez, his consistency has earned praise from teammates and coaches. “He’s gone up, he’s gone down, and he’s always answered with the right attitude,” Hinch said.

The Tigers’ decision will hinge on Verlander’s recovery timeline and the team’s need for bullpen flexibility. Montero’s willingness to adapt—whether as a starter or reliever—has not gone unnoticed. “As long as they give me the ball, I’ll do my best to help this team win,” he said.

What’s next for the Tigers’ pitching staff?

With Verlander’s return expected in the coming weeks, the Tigers must navigate roster decisions that could impact their playoff aspirations. Hinch’s emphasis on “best pitchers pitching” suggests a data-driven approach, but player development and team chemistry will also play roles.

Montero’s ability to maintain his current form will be critical. His pitch efficiency and adaptability position him as a key piece in Detroit’s long-term plans, regardless of his immediate role. As the season progresses, the Tigers’ handling of this pitching puzzle will offer insights into their competitive strategy.