Toby Carvery Contractor Identified in Ancient Oak Felling Controversy

A contractor has been identified as the party responsible for the unauthorized partial felling of a 500-year-old oak tree in Whitewebbs Park, Enfield, North London, in April 2025. The incident, which occurred near a Toby Carvery restaurant, sparked public outrage and a legal dispute with Enfield Council.

Background of the Incident

The partial felling of the oak tree, sometimes referred to as the Guy Fawkes oak, prompted widespread dismay and anger from the local community and Enfield Council. The council, which leases the land to Mitchells & Butlers Retail (M&B), the owners of Toby Carvery, was not consulted before the work was carried out. M&B initially claimed the work was necessary for safety reasons, citing concerns about the tree’s health, but experts, including investigators from the Forest Commission, found the tree to be healthy with no immediate need for felling. Enfield Council is now pursuing eviction proceedings against M&B.

Ground Control Identified as the Contractor

The Guardian has reported that documentary evidence reveals the work was undertaken by Ground Control, a maintenance business and biodiversity expert with a turnover of £190m. Ground Control agreed to remove the tree at the request of M&B, citing a large split in one of the main branches as justification.

Concerns Over Transparency and Tree Health

Dr. Ed Pyne, a senior conservation adviser at the Woodland Trust, expressed concern over the lack of transparency surrounding the felling. “It is tragic it has taken a year to find out who was behind the felling of this tree. There has been a lack of transparency throughout, so now it is time they answered some questions,” he stated.

Efforts to Save the Remaining Tree Stump

Despite the extensive damage, the remaining trunk of the oak has shown signs of regrowth. Arborist Russell Miller has suggested a “life support” system, such as a sprinkler system, could help sustain the tree, potentially costing around £10,000. This approach has been successfully used to preserve ancient trees elsewhere, including the oldest tree in Poland.

Legal and Eviction Proceedings

Enfield Council initiated legal proceedings in November 2025, seeking forfeiture of the lease held by Mitchells & Butlers Retail. The dispute is expected to be heard in court later in 2026 or early 2027. The council views the felling as a reckless act that caused irreparable damage to Enfield’s natural heritage.

Investigation and Public Response

The unauthorized felling is too the subject of an investigation by the Forestry Commission. The incident has drawn significant public attention and criticism, highlighting the importance of protecting ancient trees and ensuring transparency in land management practices.