International Edition
Latest News
Business

Pretoria Restaurant Guilty of Unlawful Automatic Service Charge, Avoids Fine

A Pretoria restaurant faced no fine after the National Consumer Tribunal ruled that its automatic addition of a 10% service charge to customer bills constitutes prohibited conduct under consumer law. BusinessTech reported that the ruling addresses a practice…

Pretoria Restaurant Guilty of Unlawful Automatic Service Charge, Avoids Fine

A Pretoria restaurant faced no fine after the National Consumer Tribunal ruled that its automatic addition of a 10% service charge to customer bills constitutes prohibited conduct under consumer law.

BusinessTech reported that the ruling addresses a practice where dining establishments apply a blanket gratuity without securing explicit upfront consent from patrons. Consumer rights expert Wendy Knowler told BusinessTech that the decision marks an important precedent for the broader hospitality sector as complaints about mandatory tips continue to rise.

The establishment processed roughly 200 service-charge transactions each day, prompting the National Consumer Commission to treat the policy as a systemic issue rather than an isolated oversight. The venue defended its billing methods by arguing that the charge was clearly printed on menus, remained discretionary upon request, and directed all collected funds straight to waitstaff.

“a discretionary charge of 10% will be added to your bill. Please notify management if the service you received is not up to standard. Management will gladly remove it from your bill,” the Pretoria restaurant's menu stated.

the Money Show

Legal arguments centered on pricing transparency and consumer autonomy within the framework of national regulations. The tribunal determined that shifting the burden onto patrons to dispute an automatic fee infringes upon their statutory rights.

Section 23 of the Consumer Protection Act establishes that suppliers cannot compel buyers to pay amounts exceeding displayed prices, according to Knowler.

“Section 23 of the Consumer Protection Act says that a supplier cannot make you pay more than the displayed price. And paying for service has always got to be voluntary and not mandatory,” she told BusinessTech.

The tribunal found that the restaurant’s approach effectively required diners to pay extra for standard service or negotiate reductions when dining experiences fell below expectations. Knowler said that customers already possess a legal guarantee to satisfactory service quality, meaning policies requiring diners to challenge extra fees effectively strip them of that statutory protection.

The National Consumer Commission initially pressed for a R1 million financial penalty against the Pretoria establishment. The tribunal ultimately declared the conduct unlawful without issuing a fine or awarding costs.

Several mitigating factors influenced the final decision, including the restaurant’s cooperation during the investigation and its willingness to remove the contested wording from menus. The tribunal established that the business acted without bad faith, as all collected gratuities reached the intended waiters and no evidence showed the company profited from the charges.

“A discretionary 10% for services that nobody has described or itemised for you doesn’t give you any certainty,” Knowler told BusinessTech.

The restaurant violated the Consumer Protection Act by automatically adding a fee that forced customers to pay more than the displayed price and challenge unsatisfactory service.

No evidence indicated the establishment profited from the charges, as the tribunal confirmed that all money collected through the 10% fee went directly to the waiters as tips.

The tribunal declared the conduct unlawful but refrained from imposing a R1 million fine or issuing a costs order due to the restaurant’s cooperation and lack of bad faith.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.