International Edition
Latest News
News

Quebec Court of Appeal Dismisses Robert Miller Appeal, Allows Class Action to Proceed

Quebec's Court of Appeal dismissed appeals by Montreal billionaire Robert Miller, his company Future Electronics and three associates on Thursday, clearing the way for a class-action lawsuit alleging the sexual exploitation of underage girls to proceed. The unanimous…

Quebec Court of Appeal Dismisses Robert Miller Appeal, Allows Class Action to Proceed

Quebec’s Court of Appeal dismissed appeals by Montreal billionaire Robert Miller, his company Future Electronics and three associates on Thursday, clearing the way for a class-action lawsuit alleging the sexual exploitation of underage girls to proceed.

The unanimous decision upholds a January 2025 Superior Court ruling that authorized the plaintiffs to pursue their allegations collectively. It does not rule on the merits of the case but allows the litigation to advance to the discovery phase, where lawyers can obtain documents and question witnesses.

“It’s obviously good news for my clients,” Jeff Orenstein, the lawyer representing the women, told Montreal Gazette. “It means we can move to step two. It does not mean that we won the case, just to be clear.”

The lawsuit, filed in February 2023, followed a joint investigation by Radio-Canada’s Enquête and CBC’s The Fifth Estate. The plaintiffs allege Miller, the founder of Future Electronics, paid underage girls for sex over several years and that associates helped recruit them and arrange encounters using company resources.

Superior Court Justice Catherine Piché concluded in her authorization ruling that approximately 100 minors, aged 11 to 17, between 1994 and 2006, could be affected by what she described as a juvenile prostitution system organized for Miller’s benefit, CBC reported.

The defendants challenged the use of 44 anonymous statements from alleged victims at the authorization stage, arguing it undermined their ability to defend themselves. The Court of Appeal ruled the statements could support the request for a class action without the court determining their veracity.

Future Electronics also contested its inclusion, arguing the alleged actions of its employees did not benefit the company.

The appeal court found a sufficient basis to examine whether the company could be held responsible for its own alleged actions or those of its employees.

The civil case proceeds against a backdrop of related criminal proceedings that ended in June 2025. Quebec Superior Court Justice Lyne Décarie stayed 24 criminal charges against Miller involving 11 complainants after ruling he was too ill to stand trial due to advanced Parkinson’s disease, effectively ending the prosecution.

Miller has denied the accusations against him. His lawyer, Karim Renno, said Thursday his team had not yet decided whether to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

“We have no comment at this time and will need to properly analyze the judgment before making a recommendation to our client regarding a possible appeal,” Renno said in an email to Montreal Gazette.

The defendants named alongside Miller and Future Electronics are Helmut Lippmann, Raymond Poulet and Sam Joseph Abrams.

Miller stepped down as CEO of Future Electronics in 2023, The Province reported.

The plaintiffs will ultimately have to prove their allegations on a balance of probabilities. Orenstein said he emailed the ruling to the women involved Thursday and had received positive replies.

“If we succeed there, then we will finally get the justice that they are seeking,” Orenstein told Montreal Gazette.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.