When comparing the Sony WH-1000XM5 and Bose QuietComfort 45 wireless noise-canceling headphones after months of daily use, reviewers at SlashGear reported distinct trade-offs in comfort, physical controls, active noise cancellation behavior, and everyday durability that marketing materials miss.
Headband Extension and Ear Cushion Comfort
The Bose QuietComfort 45 weighs about 240 grams, while the Sony WH-1000XM5 weighs 250 grams, a difference most users will not notice in daily life. However, physical dimensions and materials create divergent wear experiences. The Bose features a softer, wider headband, making it more comfortable for users who wear glasses over long listening sessions, though fully extending the band creates a bulbous shape on the back of the head. Conversely, the Sony model utilizes a telescoping adjustment mechanism that resists loosening after years of regular use and features squared-off ear cushions that accommodate a wider variety of ear shapes better than the narrower oval cups on the Bose.
Physical Buttons Versus Haptic Touch Controls
Control schemes separate the two models cleanly. Bose relies entirely on physical buttons for volume, track navigation, power, and noise cancellation modes. Skipping songs on the Bose requires pressing a small multifunction button multiple times, which can lead to mistimed inputs. Sony utilizes a haptic touch pad on the right earcup for media controls, allowing users to swipe, double-tap, and drag to adjust volume or change tracks. This touch sensor fails to register inputs when worn with standard work gloves, whereas the Bose physical buttons remain operable in cold weather.
While Sony wins the spec sheet and the silence test, Bose’s lighter fit, stronger bass, and better software make its QuietComfort Ultra 2 the pair to buyhttps://t.co/wDTDQJLQjP
— https://x.com/NewYorkSun/status/2097814832988774505
Active Noise Cancellation Quirks and Power Settings
Active noise cancellation performance comes with specific operational quirks on both devices. The Bose QC45 cannot turn ANC completely off, locking users into either quiet mode or an aware mode that channels outside sound through the microphones. The Sony WH-1000XM5 includes a speak-to-chat feature that automatically lowers volume and enables ambient sound, which users frequently disable to prevent accidental triggers. Additionally, the Sony model suffers from a known issue where it randomly powers off during use; this can be resolved by opening the Sony Sound Connect app and changing the automatic power-off setting to “Do not turn off.”
Portability and Pricing Differences
Portability and storage differences affect daily commuting. The Bose QC45 folds completely and features rotating ear cups for a compact footprint, whereas the Sony WH-1000XM5 dropped the folding mechanism of its predecessor, the WH-1000XM4. Furthermore, the Sony earcups rotate to face upward rather than flat, preventing comfortable wear around the neck and making it easy to place them backward on a flat surface. Pricing reflects their market position, with new Sony WH-1000XM5 units selling for about $230 and Bose QC45 units priced around $359, while used versions on Amazon hover near $170 for both models.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do both headphones support high-resolution audio codecs?
Sony supports the LDAC high-resolution Bluetooth codec, whereas Bose does not include a comparable high-res codec, though this difference remains imperceptible to most listeners using standard streaming platforms.
What is the proper way to fix unexpected shutdowns on the Sony WH-1000XM5?
Owners can stop random power-downs by navigating to the Sony Sound Connect companion app and switching the automatic power-off configuration to the “Do not turn off” option.
How do the used market prices compare between these two models?
Refurbished or used pairs of the Sony WH-1000XM5 and Bose QC45 sell for approximately $171 and $170 respectively on Amazon, though buyers must verify that the original carrying case is included.
Related reading