Susan Smith was unanimously denied parole on Thursday, keeping her in prison 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a South Carolina lake, according to CNN.
Smith, now 56, appeared over a video call from prison before the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons. She asked to be freed, telling the seven-person board that she felt deep remorse for killing three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex in October 1994, BBC reported.
“I know that what I did to Michael and Alex is horrible…I have a lot of remorse, and I want to say that I’m very, very sorry,” Smith said during the hearing. “They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die.”
The board rejected her request unanimously, just as it did during her first parole hearing in 2024. Under state law, Smith can apply for parole every two years because she was sentenced to life with the possibility of parole before South Carolina abolished parole for the most serious crimes.
David Smith opposes her release
David Smith, the father of Michael and Alex, urged board members to keep his ex-wife behind bars. He told the panel that he still carries the grief of burying his sons more than three decades ago, according to FOX Carolina News.
“I’m here to advocate for Michael and Alex, not for me,” David Smith told the board. “I’m just here to ask you all to look in your heart and see their father’s pain and his still broken heart, and ask your heart: Is 32 years enough for what she did to Michael and Alex?”
Former prosecutors Kevin Brackett and Tommy Pope also spoke against Smith’s release. They warned the board that Smith could profit from her crimes by selling her story to journalists or through social media.

Smith initially blamed carjacking for sons' disappearance
Smith originally told police that a Black man had carjacked her at a stoplight in Union, South Carolina, and driven away with her two sons inside the vehicle. That claim sparked a nine-day international manhunt before Smith confessed that she had strapped the boys into their car seats and allowed her Mazda to roll into John D. Long Lake.
During her trial, prosecutors argued that Smith killed her sons because a man she was having an affair with told her that children did not fit into their future. Defense lawyers maintained that she suffered a severe mental breakdown and intended to take her own life with the boys before stepping out of the vehicle at the last moment.
The South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons was created in 1941 when Governor Burnet Rhett Maybank signed Act 562, establishing the South Carolina Probation and Parole Board. Governor Maybank appointed six original members representing the state’s judicial districts, and the board held its first meeting the following day.
The board and its supervising agency became separate entities in 1994 after the General Assembly mandated a restructuring of state government. Today, the Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services is the third largest state law enforcement agency in South Carolina, supervising over 20,000 offenders in the community.
Questions about Susan Smith parole
-
When can Susan Smith apply for parole again?
Inmates serving life sentences eligible for parole in South Carolina receive a reconsideration hearing every two years following a denial. -
What vote count did Susan Smith need to secure her release?
Smith needed two-thirds of the board members present to vote in her favor to be freed, but the board voted unanimously against her release. -
Why was Smith eligible for parole after a life sentence?
She was convicted in 1995 under South Carolina laws in effect at the time, which permitted parole eligibility after serving 30 years for individuals sentenced to life.
“We are very grateful to the parole board for keeping her incarcerated for another two years,” David Smith said.
Worth a look