International Edition
Latest News
Entertainment

The Platonic Ideal of a Wine Glass’: We Test the Best for Every Budget

In a column for The Guardian, wine writer Mina Holland tests universal wine glasses across price points and names the Richard Brendon x Jancis Robinson glass the best overall at £48 each. Holland evaluated each glass with a…

The Platonic Ideal of a Wine Glass': We Test the Best for Every Budget

In a column for The Guardian, wine writer Mina Holland tests universal wine glasses across price points and names the Richard Brendon x Jancis Robinson glass the best overall at £48 each.

Holland evaluated each glass with a sparkling wine, a chilled white and a room-temperature red, judging aroma concentration, comfort, stability and the “ineffable metric of how much joy it brought me,” she writes in The Guardian. She tested over several weeks, pouring no more than a third full and swirling before tasting. She also assessed practicality, whether the glasses are dishwasher safe, how easy they are to wash and dry, how clearly the wine can be seen and whether the glass allows the wine to breathe.

“A good glass can greatly improve your experience,” writes David Williams in The Encyclopedia of Wine. He adds that expense isn’t necessary: “[A]s a rule, the thinner the glass the better, while an oval shape and generous (but not enormous) bowl are best at capturing and releasing a wine’s flavours.”

The Richard Brendon x Jancis Robinson glass, mouth-blown with a 9 cm bowl that narrows to a thin rim, earned five stars. “The platonic ideal of a wine glass: perfectly proportioned with an elegant tulip shape,” Holland writes. The glass is sold in pairs for £96 at Selfridges and Borough Kitchen.

Jancis Robinson, a Master of Wine who collaborated on the design, “champions the idea that none of us need more than one shape of wine glass,” Holland reports, quoting Robinson: “just one glass for all wines makes perfect practical sense.”

The Platonic Ideal of a Wine Glass': We Test the Best for Every Budget
Photo: inkl.com

For budget buyers, Tesco’s F&F Home premium wine glasses cost £3.50 each, or £14 for four. “I’m so impressed by this glass! For only £3.50 a pop, you get a generous bowl and proportions that mimic all the best stemmed universal glasses in this test,” Holland writes. The glasses are dishwasher-safe and their heavier stem steadies the hand for swirling.

The Lehmann F Sommier Psyché, at £18.33 each (£110 for six at Borough Kitchen), became Holland’s daily driver. “Since the test, this has been the glass I have kept reaching for day-to-day, especially if I have wines to taste for my column,” she writes. The machine-made glass has the most generous bowl among the premium options tested and is dishwasher-safe.

Zalto’s universal glass, priced at £50 each (£100 for two at Borough Kitchen), carries a cult following. “These are cult wine glasses – so revered that I know a sommelier who named their dog after them,” Holland writes. The rim measures half a millimetre thick. “Guests don’t want the responsibility!” she adds, noting she rarely uses her wedding-gift set except for special wines.

For parties, Olympia short-stemmed glasses cost £2.94 each (£17.62 for six at Nisbets). “At this price, I don’t need to be precious about breakages – rare in any case since they are so robust,” Holland writes. The 13.5 cm glasses suit “everything from vin de table to party plonk” but lack the height for serious swirling.

Other glasses tested include Iittala Lempi (£13.75–£14.89 each), Bloomingville Signe (£8 each), Toast recycled Bolivian (£9 each), Nkuku Sigiri (£8.40 each), Habitat bobbin (£3.38 each) and Ichendorf Milano Courgette (£24.99 each). Holland found tinted or fluted bowls obscure wine colour, while small or thick-rimmed designs limit swirling and aroma concentration.

Robinson, born in 1950 in Carlisle, became the first person outside the wine trade to earn the Master of Wine qualification in 1984. She edited The Oxford Companion to Wine, first published in 1994, and co-authored The World Atlas of Wine and the 1,368-variety reference Wine Grapes. She writes a weekly column for the Financial Times and advised the wine cellar of Queen Elizabeth II.

Holland discloses she is a wine columnist for The Guardian and a parent in her 40s who “takes time over a glass or two and want that experience to be as lovely as possible.” She notes a personal preference for hand-washing fine glassware despite manufacturers’ dishwasher-safe claims.

About the author: Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archynewsy.