Three years after the Nova massacre, survivors face persistent trauma and gaps in state care.
SafeHeart’s second annual conference convened on Wednesday at the Peres Center for Peace and Innovation in Jaffa, where researchers, clinicians, and families examined why recovery has stalled for many of the roughly 3,500 people who attended the festival on Oct. 7, 2023, The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported.
About three-quarters of Nova survivors were between 18 and 24 when the attack killed more than 300 people at the site near Kibbutz Re’im, accounting for nearly one-third of the approximately 1,200 people killed that day, JNS reported. Three years later, 79% of survivors have been recognized as having a psychiatric disability, while only about 60% are employed, SafeHeart CEO Efrat Atun told JNS.
Distress deepens as public attention fades
More survivors are seeking psychiatric treatment now than a year ago, and SafeHeart’s team handling complex cases is “flooded with cases,” Atun told JNS. “The massacre interrupted their lives just as they were getting started. From previous years, we know that distress peaks precisely when the spotlight fades. That is why continuity of care matters now more than ever,” she said.
Ayelet Cohen-Wieder, a clinical psychologist who works with SafeHeart, rated the state’s response at three or four out of 10, citing insufficient funding and limited access to treatment.
She told JNS that only a small portion of SafeHeart’s budget comes from the government through the National Insurance Institute and Health Ministry, with most funding coming from donations.
She also criticized the process of seeking assistance through the Israel Ministry of Defense, saying its bureaucratic complexity causes some people to abandon their claims without receiving help. “Our government didn’t learn what they have to learn,” Cohen-Wieder told JNS.
First-year data show symptoms rarely remit on their own
Prof. Yuval Neria of Columbia University and the New York State Psychiatric Institute presented findings from a study of 392 Nova survivors assessed twice during the first year after the attack. About 67% scored above a screening threshold for probable PTSD at one to five months. At eight to 12 months, about 65% remained above that threshold, The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported.
Roughly 29% had persistently high symptoms, and in 26% symptoms worsened — together accounting for about 55% of the group. About a quarter followed a course of relatively low symptoms, described by researchers as resilient, while a fifth partially improved. Childhood adversity and poorer sleep after the attack were associated with lower odds of following a resilient course, Neria said. He urged clinicians to ask about sleep and address difficulties early.
Moral injury and the limits of “time heals”
Neria described “moral injury” as lasting distress following experiences that violate deeply held moral beliefs. For Nova survivors, this includes guilt about being alive when friends were killed or taken hostage, anguish over being unable to help, and a sense of betrayal after waiting hours for rescue.
“Such guilt obviously does not mean a survivor was responsible for what happened, but it can nevertheless shape how they understand their survival and whether they feel able to trust others,” The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported. The practical implication, Neria emphasized, is to ask about guilt, shame, and anger alongside fear.
Biological markers and substance use patterns
University of Haifa professors Roee Admon and Roy Salomon presented preliminary findings from an observational project involving 1,268 survivors, with a comparison group drawn from the Israeli trance music community. Survivors with higher levels of an inflammatory protein measured in saliva early after the attack tended to report more severe post-traumatic stress symptoms later, even after accounting for initial symptom severity. The finding has not yet been published and requires replication, the researchers said.
Among 453 survivors surveyed eight to 12 months afterward, about 70% reported using more than one type of psychoactive substance, including alcohol. Researchers used a language model to examine survivors’ accounts of what they took, how they experienced it, and the effects they attributed to different substances. Participants chose what to take; researchers did not assign substances, so associations cannot establish causation, The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported.

Caution on psychedelic treatment for this population
Prof. Rachel Yehuda, director of Mount Sinai’s Parsons Research Center for Psychedelic Healing, urged caution about treating festival survivors with psychedelics. For people who may have been under the influence when the massacre began, another altered experience should not automatically become the first approach to treatment, she suggested. “The desire for relief is understandable, but an experience that offers escape and one that helps a person work through trauma are not necessarily the same thing,” The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported.
Yehuda argued that any Israeli approval process for psychedelic medicines should address the psychological care accompanying their use rather than focusing only on the drugs. “Supportive psychological care is an essential part of treatment with psychedelic drugs,” she said. Training therapists and defining appropriate care must happen before patterns of treatment become well-established.
Father urges active outreach for struggling survivors
Ronen Shalev, whose son Roei survived the festival and died by suicide in October 2025, spoke at the conference about the distance between what he could see outwardly and his son’s suffering. He described not knowing which tools to ask for and urged those working with survivors to actively seek out people who are struggling.
The conference took place at the Peres Center for Peace and Innovation, an independent non-profit founded in 1996 by Nobel Peace Laureate and former President Shimon Peres to advance his vision of Middle East peace through socio-economic cooperation and people-to-people interaction. Since 2009, it has operated from the Peres Peace House in Jaffa’s Ajami neighborhood, which also houses the Shimon Peres Archives and hosts coexistence programs for local communities.
Continuity of care over years
SafeHeart, founded as an emergency mental health initiative on Oct. 7, 2023, now operates a network of about 400 therapists specializing in trauma, including practitioners familiar with psychedelic experiences, providing long-term individual treatment to more than 1,000 survivors, Atun told JNS. The organization has provided more than 75,000 hours of therapy. Cohen-Wieder estimated that roughly half of SafeHeart’s survivors had made substantial progress in integrating the trauma into their lives.
Some have created music, shared their experiences internationally, or developed startups addressing stress and anxiety. “But progress can coexist with acute anxiety, and renewed security threats can cause setbacks. Every alarm could cause you to freeze for a day, or sometimes more than a day,” Cohen-Wieder told JNS.
“It takes continuity of care and a commitment that lasts for years,” Atun said.
Worth a look
- Irish Student Sophie Keane Wins World Youth Entrepreneurship Challenge in New York
- Meta Stuck in $500-$800 Range for Two Years
- Wreck of Australia’s first warship built at home found 128 years after sinking (newsylist.com)
- RBA's Fifth Hike Adds About A$94 a Month on A$600,000; Three Voted to Hold (daybreakwire.com)