The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission proposed in September 2026 to rescind Rule 14a-8, the federal standard that has governed shareholder proposals since 1942, and return oversight to state corporation law and company bylaws.
Comments were due to the SEC by November 20, 2026.
What the SEC proposed
The commission issued two related proposals on September 16, 2026. The first would rescind Rule 14a-8 entirely, leaving the terms of shareholder proposals to state law and corporate governing documents. The second would amend Rule 14a-4(c) to let companies exercise discretionary proxy voting authority on proposals omitted from their proxy statements, unless a shareholder checks a box on the proxy card to block that discretion, Legal 500 reported.
The SEC also proposed eliminating the requirement to deliver a separate annual report to security holders when a Form 10-K is already on file, and removing the 20-business-day delivery deadline for documents incorporated by reference into a proxy statement.
Investors and faith groups warn of lost influence
CalPERS and other institutional investors told the SEC the rule gives shareholders their only reliable path to raise financial risks — from climate transition to human rights — before they become systemic, according to Pensions & Investments. The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) said it has filed proposals for more than 55 years, starting with a 1974 request that companies disclose operations in Apartheid South Africa.
During the proxy seasons from 2021 to 2026, the Board of Pensions and the Presbyterian Foundation through their Mission Responsibility Through Investment committee filed about 60 shareholder proposals and withdrew more than half after reaching agreements with companies, the denomination’s Stated Clerk, the Rev. Jihyun Oh, wrote in a comment letter.

“The resolution process facilitated meaningful conversation and most of the resolutions were later withdrawn,” Oh wrote. “Without the shareholder proposal process, Presbyterians would lose an important avenue for bringing faith-based concerns to corporate leadership and investors would lose the opportunity to vote on issues that reflect their values.”
Ceres, a sustainability nonprofit, said investors filed 264 proposals asking companies to assess and disclose financial sustainability risks from 2002 through 2024. By 2025, 94 percent of S&P 500 companies issued sustainability reports, up from a minority two decades earlier, Ceres told the SEC. The group also cited the spread of annual director elections: roughly 40 percent of S&P 500 boards had them in 1999 versus 88 percent by 2025, a shift it attributes to shareholder proposals.
“Shareholder proposals often flag significant financial issues, from those related to extreme weather to transition risk, before they become systemic problems, and they help companies address these issues and strengthen long-term value,” said Steven Rothstein, chief program officer at Ceres.

Business groups and state lawmakers prepare alternatives
“before rescission takes effect. The prosperity-generating power of free-market capitalism must be defended against the myriad conflicts of interest distorting relevant inputs,” the Heritage Foundation wrote on the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance.
Delaware, where most large U.S. corporations are incorporated, circulated a discussion draft in November 2026 that would create a new statutory right for stockholders to include precatory (non-binding) proposals in proxy statements of companies with at least $30 billion in market capitalization, Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP reported.
The draft would set a $250,000 ownership threshold for individuals, limit the number of proposals to between one and three depending on company size, and exclude binding proposals such as bylaw amendments or director removal.
Texas amended its Business Organizations Code in 2025 to impose ownership thresholds, continuous holding requirements, and solicitation rules for shareholder proposals, but the statute applies only to corporations that affirmatively opt in, Hunton Andrews Kurth noted. No state has yet enacted a comprehensive replacement for Rule 14a-8.
SEC comment period closed; decisions and litigation ahead
The SEC’s public comment period closed November 20, 2026. The commission must now review the record and decide whether to adopt, modify, or withdraw the proposals. Litigation is widely expected if the rescission is finalized, and it is unclear whether a court would stay the rule’s repeal while challenges proceed, according to Hunton Andrews Kurth.
The SEC was created by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, enacted after the 1929 crash and the Pecora Commission hearings exposed widespread market abuses.
The law transferred enforcement of the 1933 Securities Act from the Federal Trade Commission to the new independent agency and gave it authority over exchanges such as the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ. Its three-part mission is to protect investors; maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets; and facilitate capital formation.
Delaware’s State Bar Association must still approve the discussion draft before it reaches the General Assembly, and its legislative prospects remain uncertain.