A London tribunal confirmed Thursday that the British government issued a secret order compelling Apple to build a backdoor into its encrypted iCloud storage, rejecting the Home Office’s argument that acknowledging the notice would damage national security.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled that extensive public reporting — including statements by former U.S. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard and articles in the Financial Times and The Washington Post — had already placed the order’s existence in the public domain, making the government’s “neither confirm nor deny” stance untenable, and said the government had not established that revealing the Home Office gave Apple a technical capability notice would damage national security. The order, known as a technical capability notice (TCN), was first issued in January 2025 and demanded access to the encrypted cloud backups of both U.K. and U.S. citizens through Apple’s Advanced Data Protection feature, according to Reuters. That demand was dropped after months of negotiations with the Trump administration, but a second notice targeting only British users’ data followed in July 2025, Reuters reported. Apple responded to the initial order by withdrawing Advanced Data Protection for new U.K. users rather than comply. The company told TechCrunch it welcomes the tribunal’s decision to publicize the notice’s existence and reiterated it has “never built a backdoor or master key” to any product.
Lawyers for Liberty and Privacy International, which brought the challenge alongside two individuals, called the Home Office’s refusal to confirm the order “farcical” after U.S. lawmakers and unnamed British officials had already discussed it in media briefings. The tribunal agreed, citing reports in The Times and Financial Times that appeared to originate from “private media briefings provided by government officials,” the BBC reported.
“Encryption protects the things that matter most to us — including our family photos, personal messages, bank details and health records,” said Akiko Hart, director of Liberty. “At a time of growing cyber threats, governments should be rising to the challenge to strengthen digital security protections rather than opening the door to hackers and hostile actors.”
A Home Office spokesperson said the right to privacy is crucial but “should not come at the expense of public safety,” adding that Apple has assisted police and intelligence agencies for years and the notice “simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so.”
The department did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment on the ruling. Thursday’s decision addresses only whether the notice can be acknowledged. A trial on the substance of the case is not expected until next year, and a final hearing on Liberty’s challenge to the TCN itself is scheduled for 2027.
Worth a look
- Telcel and AT&T Suffer Widespread Outages Across México; Carriers Blame External Causes
- Twisting Anisotropic 2D Semiconductors Enables Full Control of Infrared Wavelength and Polarization
- Bally’s Chairman Soo Kim Confirms $250M for Vegas Stadium After Tense Exchange (news-usa.today)
- OLED iMac plans may be cancelled by Apple for two reasons (newsylist.com)