International Edition
Latest News
World

UN Geneva Conference Ends Without Binding Killer Robot Treaty; Two-Year Process Approved

One hundred twenty-eight nations concluded a weeklong United Nations conference in Geneva on Saturday without securing an agreement to ban or limit lethal autonomous weapons. The gathering brought together member states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons…

UN Geneva Conference Ends Without Binding Killer Robot Treaty; Two-Year Process Approved

One hundred twenty-eight nations concluded a weeklong United Nations conference in Geneva on Saturday without securing an agreement to ban or limit lethal autonomous weapons.

The gathering brought together member states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons to address systems that select and engage targets based on sensor processing rather than human input. While roughly 100 countries and United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres pushed for legally binding rules, major military powers resisted a strict mandate.

Disarmament advocates and international organizations criticized the outcome as inadequate for addressing rapidly advancing military artificial intelligence. “Delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk,” said Nicole van Rooijen, executive director of Stop Killer Robots.

Despite the lack of an immediate treaty, delegates approved a two-year process to develop new rules and consider whether future measures should carry legal force. Izumi Nakamitsu, the United Nations disarmament chief, said that the path toward a binding instrument remains open.

Military Opposition and Diplomatic Divisions

Resistance from prominent arms-producing countries shaped the final days of the Geneva negotiations, which concluded past 4 a.m. on Saturday. The United States, Russia, and Israel opposed establishing a short-term, legally binding framework during the review conference.

UN Geneva Conference Ends Without Binding Killer Robot Treaty; Two-Year Process Approved
Photo: The Jerusalem Post

Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova told reporters on Wednesday that Moscow viewed discussions on strict restrictions as premature. Russia wanted organizational matters ironed out first and sought a process free from politicization.

Conversely, China expressed willingness to move toward a legally binding international protocol. Ukraine stressed the need for meaningful human control as it uses drones with autonomous capabilities in the war with Russia.

Julien Thöni, the Swiss diplomat who presided over the conference, defended the compromise. He said that the commitment from major military powers to continue discussions amid severe geopolitical tension showed that multilateral diplomacy can still deliver results.

Humanitarian Warnings and Religious Stance

Humanitarian groups and religious authorities argued that delegating life-and-death choices to machines strips warfare of moral judgment. The International Committee of the Red Cross expressed regret that delegates missed an opportunity to secure an immediate negotiation mandate.

UN Geneva Conference Ends Without Binding Killer Robot Treaty; Two-Year Process Approved
Photo: Vatican News

“States must launch negotiations on a new protocol before it is too late,” the ICRC said in a statement. The organization warned that today’s technologically sophisticated conflicts have not generated better outcomes for civilians.

The Holy See submitted a position paper to the conference arguing that machines perform only calculations, whereas moral judgment involves conscience and personal responsibility. “Machines can make only calculations, and moral judgement cannot be reduced to a calculation; it involves conscience, personal responsibility and recognizing others as people,” the Vatican said in its document, calling for a moratorium on lethal autonomous weapons systems.

Future Timeline for Autonomous Weapon Rules

Negotiation Status on Autonomous Weapons
Entity Stance Proposed Action
Around 100 Nations Supportive Immediate legally binding rules
US, Russia, Israel Opposed Resisted strict binding restrictions
UN Geneva Conference Compromise Develop rules over the next two years

The newly established mandate tasks a group of governmental experts with developing an international instrument and making recommendations on its legal nature over the next two years. “creates a platform for discussion that leaves room for reaching a protocol” said Bonnie Docherty, a senior arms adviser to Human Rights Watch.

Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of non-governmental organizations, was first launched in April 2013 to urge governments to outlaw the development of lethal autonomous weapons. The group has since been recognized for its advocacy, winning the Ypres Peace Prize in 2020 and receiving the Archivio Disarmo – Golden Doves for Peace award in 2024.

Its efforts have included mobilizing public opposition, such as a 2018 global poll that found 61% of adults across 26 countries opposed to the use of such systems, and garnering support from experts and technology companies concerned about an arms race in military artificial intelligence.

“States need to deliver the majority’s call for a new treaty,” Docherty said.

Earlier coverage: UN 'Killer Robots' Talks End Friday Without Decision to Start Treaty Talks

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.