International Edition
Latest News
Health

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases

University Hospital Zurich has paid compensation in 14 cases tied to the cardiac surgery scandal that led to the dismissal of former clinic chief Francesco Maisano, the hospital confirmed Wednesday. The payments total a low six-figure sum. They…

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases

University Hospital Zurich has paid compensation in 14 cases tied to the cardiac surgery scandal that led to the dismissal of former clinic chief Francesco Maisano, the hospital confirmed Wednesday.

The payments total a low six-figure sum. They were disclosed in a written statement obtained by Keystone-SDA and first reported by Swiss public radio SRF. Twenty compensation claims have been filed to date; six remain pending. The hospital said it has reached out-of-court settlements with all claimants so far, and no legal proceedings have been initiated, Swissinfo reported.

Sixty-eight to 74 excess deaths

The scandal erupted in May when an external investigation found that between 68 and 74 more patients died after heart surgery at the USZ than statistically expected over a period covering roughly 4,500 operations. Those patients might still be alive had they been treated at a different hospital, the investigators concluded.

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases
Photo: ctol.digital

Criminal inquiry centres on Cardioband

Zurich prosecutors are now investigating three cases on suspicion of negligent homicide, negligent grievous bodily harm, and document forgery. The prosecutor’s office also received 11 reports concerning the inappropriate use of medical devices, Swissinfo reported.

At the centre of the criminal inquiry is the Cardioband, a mitral valve repair device Maisano helped develop. Prosecutors allege he used the implant even when it was not the appropriate clinical choice and that he benefited financially from its use. Maisano has denied wrongdoing through his legal representatives.

Warnings ignored for years

The hospital’s handling of early warnings has drawn sharp criticism. Former cardiac surgery co-chief André Plass filed internal complaints as early as 2019 regarding Maisano’s practices and the Cardioband’s safety profile. UZH leadership initially backed Maisano and dismissed whistleblowers, including Plass, who was later dismissed himself. The hospital only moved against Maisano after the allegations became public.

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases
Photo: bluewin.ch

Germany’s Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM) issued four safety warnings for the Cardioband, including reports of device screws loosening and migrating into a patient’s heart chamber. Despite the alerts, the device remained in use at USZ and other institutions, including Berlin’s Charité hospital, CTOL Digital reported.

Earlier confidential deals

The compensation payments confirmed Wednesday are the first the hospital has publicly acknowledged.

The external investigation commissioned by the hospital board was published in May. The Zurich District Attorney’s Office confirmed the criminal investigations are ongoing. No trial dates have been set.

About the author: Health Desk

Health Desk at Archynewsy.