aespa Member Giselle Surprised by Fan Singalongs at Birthday Party
Girl group aespa member Giselle held a birthday party on the 30th, during which assembled fans sang a birthday song, causing Giselle to appear shocked by their singing skills, kagit.kr reported. Prior to the singing, Giselle had specifically asked the fans to sing the birthday song in Korean.
Fan Vocal Performances Mirror Past Ningning Birthday Incident
The vocal misfire closely mirrored an earlier incident during member Ningning’s birthday party, where fans similarly struggled with pitch and timing. While some online observers previously attributed Ningning’s event to language barriers because those attendees sang in Chinese, the latest party featured fans singing in Korean. Commentators across Korean online communities noted that the persistence of out-of-tune group singing proved language was never the underlying issue.
Fan Reactions and Member Comments Highlighted Online
Korean online forums quickly filled with humorous reactions to clips from the birthday broadcast. Viewers pointed out that Karina was overheard on the stream stating that the fans really could not sing. Other commenters joked that the group’s fandom, MY, maintained a consistent and unwavering talent for missing the beat even when instrumental accompaniment was clearly provided. Additional online remarks noted that Winter’s voice was completely drowned out by the fans, and observers questioned how an entire crowd could manage to sing so uniformly out of sync despite the loud volume and confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did Giselle host her birthday party?
Giselle held her birthday celebration on November 30, capturing attention online after fan participation went viral across Korean community boards.
Which other aespa members attended the celebration?
Members Karina and Winter were present at the event and were caught reacting to the unexpected vocal performance by the audience.
How did fans explain the out-of-tune singing?
Some attendees at the venue defended the performance by arguing that the official backing track played at a slower tempo than expected.
Related reading