Ampant Violations in Tunisia Expose EU Complicity Risk

by Ibrahim Khalil - World Editor
0 comments

The Tunisian authorities have over the past three years increasingly dismantled protections for refugees, asylum seekers and migrants, particularly Black peopel, with a dangerous shift towards racist policing and widespread human rights violations that endanger their lives, safety and dignity, Amnesty International said today. The European Union risks complicity by maintaining cooperation on migration control without effective human rights safeguards.

In a new report, ‘Nobody Hears You When You Scream’: Dangerous Shift in Tunisia’s Migration Policy, Amnesty International has documented how, fuelled by racist rhetoric from officials, tunisian authorities have carried out racially targeted arrests and detentions; reckless interceptions at sea; collective expulsions of tens of thousands of refugees and migrants to Algeria and libya; and subjected refugees and migrants to torture and other ill-treatment, including rape and other sexual violence, while cracking down on civil society providing critical assistance.

In June 2024, Tunisian authorities ordered an end to the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) role in processing asylum claims, removing the only avenue for seeking asylum in the country. Yet EU cooperation with Tunisia on migration control has continued without effective human rights safeguards, risking EU complicity in serious violations and trapping more people where their lives and rights are at risk.

“The Tunisian authorities have presided over horrific human rights violations, stoking xenophobia, while dealing blow after blow to refugee protection.They must promptly reverse this devastating rollback by ending racist incitement and stopping collective expulsions that threaten lives.They must protect the right to asylum and ensure that they don’t expel anyone to places where they would be at risk of serious human rights violations. NGO staff and human rights defenders detained for assisting refugees and migrants must be released unconditionally,” said Heba MorayevRegional Director for the Middle East and North Africa at Amnesty International.

“The EU must urgently suspend any migration and border control assistance aimed at containing people in Tunisia and halt funding to security forces or other entities responsible for human rights violations against refugees and migrants. Instead of prioritizing containment and fuelling violations, EU cooperation with Tunisia must shift its focus to ensuring adequate protection measures and asylum procedures are available in the country, and incorporate clear, enforceable human rights benchmarks and conditions, to avoid complicity in violations.”

Amnesty International conducted research between February 2023 and June 2023 and interviewed 120 refugees and migrants from nearly 20 countries (92 men, 28 women, eight children aged 16–17) in Tunis, sfax, and Zarzis. The institution also reviewed UN, media, and civil society sources and the official pages of local tunisian authorities. Ahead of publication, Amnesty shared its findings with Tunisian, European, and Libyan authorities.No response had been received by the time of publication.

A crisis fuelled by racist rhetoric

Testimonies reveal a migration and asylum system designed to exclude and punish rather than protect. At least 60 of those interviewed by Amnesty, including three childrentwo refugees and five asylum seekers, were arbitrarily arrested and detained. Black refugees and migrants were targeted amid systemic racial profiling and successive waves of racist violence from individuals and security forces, triggered by the public advocacy of racial hatred, starting with President kais Saied’s remarks in February 2023 and echoed by other officials and parliamentarians since.

The Tunisian authorities have presided over horrific human rights violations, stoking xenophobia, while dealing blow after blow to refugee protection. They must immediately reverse this devastating rollback by ending racist incitement and stopping collective expulsions that threaten lives.

Heba Morayef, Amnesty International

The situation was aggravated by a surge of repressive measures targeting at least six NGOs providing critical support to refugees and migrants. This has had horrific humanitarian consequences and led to an enormous gap in protection. Since May 2024authorities have arbitrarily detained at least eight NGO workers and two former local officials who cooperated with them. The next hearing in the trial of the staff of one of these organizations,the Tunisian Council for Refugeesis scheduled for 24 November.

‘We saw them drown’

Amnesty International investigated 24 interceptions at sea and spoke to 25 refugees and migrants who described life-threatening, reckless and violent behavior by the Tunisian coastguard, such as dangerous ramming; high-speed manoeuvres threatening to capsize boats; hitting people and boats with batons; firing tear gas at close range; and the denial of any individualised protection assessment at disembarkation.

“Céline”, a Cameroonian woman migrant intercepted after departing from the eastern region of Sfax in June 2023, told Amnesty International:

“They kept hitting our [wooden] boat with long batons with sharp endings, they pierced it… There were at least two women and three babies without life vests. We saw them drown and then we could not see the bodies anymore. I have never been so scared.”

Despite ongoing concerns about the lack of obvious reporting regarding interceptions, in 2024 the Tunisian authorities stopped publicly sharing data on these operations after establishing a maritime search and rescue region (SRR) supported by the EU. Prior to that, they had reported a meaningful increase in interceptions.

‘Go to Libya, they will kill you’

from June 2023 onwards, Tunisian authorities started to collectively expel tens of thousands of refugees and migrants, mostly Black people, either following racially motivated arrests or following interceptions at sea. Amnesty International found that between June 2023 and May 2025, authorities carried out at least 70 collective expulsions, involving more than 11,500 people.

Tunisian security forces have been routinely dumping migrants,asylum seekers and refugees,including pregnant women and children,in remote and desert areas at the country’s borders with Libya and Algeria.They abandoned them without food or water and usually after confiscating their phones, identification documents and money, placing them at great risk to their lives and safety. Following the first wave of expulsions in June-July 2023, at least 28 migrants were found dead along the Libyan-Tunisian border and 80 migrants were reported missing.

These expulsions have been carried out without any procedural safeguards and in violation of the principle of non-refoulement.

While people pushed toward Algeria had to walk back from the border over weeks or faced risks of “chain refoulement” from Algeria to Niger, those sent toward Libya were often handed to the libyan Border Guards or other militias who left them stranded or detained them in abusive facilities.Refugees and migrants in Human Rights Abuses Against Migrants at the Tunisia-libya Border

A United Nations fact-finding mission has found that migrants, particularly sub-Saharan Africans, attempting to cross or already present in Libya, face widespread and systematic human rights violations and abuses carried out with impunity. These abuses, occurring at the tunisia-libya border and within Libya itself, amount to crimes against humanity.

The Situation in Libya

Libya has long been a transit point for migrants and refugees seeking to reach europe. However, the country’s ongoing political instability and fragmented security landscape have created a breeding ground for human rights abuses. Migrants are routinely subjected to arbitrary detention, torture, sexual violence, extortion, and forced labor by state and non-state actors, including armed groups.

Crimes Against Humanity

The UN fact-finding mission’s findings indicate that the scale and systematic nature of these abuses meet the threshold for crimes against humanity. This designation underscores the severity of the situation and the urgent need for accountability.

abuses at the Tunisia-Libya Border

Recent reports highlight a disturbing trend of Tunisian security forces forcibly expelling migrants, including vulnerable individuals like children, to the Libyan border. These expulsions often occur without due process and expose migrants to further risks of abuse in Libya.

Forced Expulsions and Ill-Treatment

accounts from migrants, such as “Ezra,” an Ivorian man interviewed by Amnesty International, detail harrowing experiences of being forcibly expelled from Sfax, Tunisia, to the Libyan border in July 2023. Tunisian security forces reportedly destroyed migrants’ phones and offered them a stark choice: attempt to swim across the border or walk into Libya, with threats of violence. This demonstrates a callous disregard for the safety and dignity of migrants.

Vulnerability of Expelled Migrants

Those forcibly returned to Libya face immediate danger. The Libyan border zone is controlled by armed groups who routinely exploit, abuse, and extort migrants. The lack of legal protection and the prevalence of impunity further exacerbate the risks.

Impunity and Lack of Accountability

A key factor contributing to the perpetuation of these abuses is the widespread impunity enjoyed by perpetrators. Libyan authorities have consistently failed to investigate and prosecute those responsible for human rights violations. The lack of accountability encourages further abuses and undermines the rule of law.

International Response and Recommendations

The UN fact-finding mission has called for urgent action to address the deteriorating human rights situation in Libya. Key recommendations include:

  • Accountability: Investigating and prosecuting those responsible for human rights violations and crimes against humanity.
  • Protection of Migrants: Ensuring the protection of migrants and refugees, including access to asylum procedures and humanitarian assistance.
  • Border Monitoring: Independent monitoring of the Tunisia-Libya border to prevent and document abuses.
  • international Cooperation: Increased international cooperation to address the root causes of migration and provide support to Libya in strengthening its human rights protections.

Key Takeaways

  • Migrants in Libya are facing systematic human rights abuses that constitute crimes against humanity.
  • Tunisian security forces are forcibly expelling migrants to the dangerous Libyan border.
  • impunity for perpetrators is a major obstacle to improving the human rights situation.
  • Urgent international action is needed to protect migrants and hold those responsible accountable.

The situation at the Tunisia-Libya border and within Libya demands immediate attention. Without concerted efforts to address the root causes of these abuses and ensure accountability, the suffering of migrants will continue unabated. The international community must prioritize the protection of vulnerable populations and work towards a sustainable solution that respects the human rights of all.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment