America’s Premier Pizzerias: The 50 Top Pizza USA 2025 Results
The quest for the perfect pizza in the United States has a definitive starting point: the 50 Top Pizza USA ranking.Widely respected as a leading authority in the global pizza landscape, this annual guide recently unveiled its 2025 selections, reaffirming una Pizza Napoletana in New York City as the nation’s top pizzeria for an unprecedented third consecutive year. Beyond the overall rankings, the guide also spotlighted exceptional slice shops and presented special accolades recognizing innovation in areas like complementary cuisine and beverage programs.
Understanding the 50 Top Pizza Guide
50 Top Pizza operates through a rigorous, anonymous inspection process conducted across the U.S. and internationally. Evaluators don’t simply assess the pizza itself; their focus extends to the entire dining experience,prioritizing the holistic wellbeing of the customer. This complete approach ensures that only establishments demonstrating a commitment to quality across all facets of operation earn recognition.
According to the guide’s editorial team – Barbara Guerra, Luciano Pignataro, and Albert Sapere – the American pizza scene is experiencing a period of dynamic evolution. “We consistently observe pizzerias throughout the United States embracing novel concepts,which ultimately benefits the industry as a whole,” thay state. “Furthermore, the increasing diversity of pizza styles available to consumers is a positive trend, offering a broader range of choices and culinary experiences.”
Highlights from the 2025 Awards Ceremony
The 2025 50 Top Pizza USA awards were presented on July 1st at West Edge, within the vibrant Chelsea Market in New York City. The event, livestreamed across the guide’s social media platforms, was emceed by renowned pizza expert scott Wiener of Scott’s Pizza Tours.
Una Pizza Napoletana, helmed by Anthony Mangieri, once again claimed the coveted number one position. The guide lauded the pizzeria as “a benchmark for pizza quality in the United States.” Securing second place was Pizzeria Sei in Los Angeles, under the direction of William Joo, while Tony’s Pizza Napoletana in San francisco, led by the celebrated Tony Gemignani, rounded out the top three.
Further notable placements within the top ten included Jay’s in Kenmore, Ribalta in New York, Robert’s in Chicago, and Don Antonio in New York. Miami demonstrated a strong presence, with both La Leggenda and ‘Or munaciello sharing the tenth-place ranking.
The guide also acknowledged the best pizza-by-the-slice establishments. The Pizzeria Industries in New York, a venture by Massimo Laveglia and Nick Baglivo, earned the top spot in this category. Slice & Pie in Washington,D.C.,followed in second,and Taglio in Mineola,New York,completed the top three.
Following the formal ceremony, attendees continued the celebration with a casual gathering at La Devozione NYC.
the top twelve pizzerias from the U.S. list, alongside the three leading slice shops, will automatically qualify for consideration in the forthcoming 100 Best Pizzerias in the World ranking, scheduled for release later this year. This inclusion provides these American establishments with international exposure and recognition.