Bridging Digital Assets and Islamic Finance
The Pakistan Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (PVARA) is moving to draw a hard line between speculative cryptocurrencies and asset-backed digital tokens. Chairman Bilal bin Saqib has opened direct talks with the Jamia Darul Uloom seminary, hoping to categorize these instruments individually rather than bundling them into a single, uniform class.
The push follows a June 10 fatwa issued by Mufti Taqi Usmani and six other scholars. That decree explicitly declared the use of cryptocurrency for purchasing goods “impermissible” under Shariah law.
Defining Wealth Under Shariah Law
At the heart of the standoff is a fundamental question of Islamic finance: does a digital asset qualify as recognized wealth? Saqib is looking to the seminary to help draft a licensing framework that accounts for these varying use cases.
Saqib maintains that blockchain is merely a verification tool, not a financial asset in its own right. His proposed framework distinguishes between two classes:
- Asset-backed tokens: Instruments like blockchain-recorded sukuk (Islamic bonds) or gold-backed tokens that represent ownership of tangible, income-generating assets.
- Speculative tokens: Digital assets lacking underlying collateral, which remain the primary focus of scholarly concern.
Market Resilience Amid Legal Uncertainty
Despite the shadow cast by the fatwa, Pakistan’s digital asset market has held steady. Waqas Ghani, head of research at JS Global Capital, notes that while the decree could present a challenge to bank-led adoption outside of urban trading hubs, current retail trading volumes in Pakistan—historically among the highest globally—have not shown a significant decline.
Seeking a Shariah-Compliant Future
The PVARA remains bullish on Pakistan’s potential to lead in Shariah-compliant digital finance. Saqib described his recent discussions with Mufti Usmani as “constructive,” aiming to demonstrate that stablecoins and tokenized real-world assets offer utility that is fundamentally different from purely speculative trading.
The regulator is now working to weave scholarly oversight directly into the licensing process. As the PVARA advances its work on stablecoins and tokenized real-world assets, the authority intends to ensure that these technologies meet the requirements for Shariah compliance. Success, Saqib argues, hinges on the ability to categorize assets by their underlying economic reality—a step he views as essential to building a sustainable, regulated digital economy.
Related reading