Denis O’brien Found Liable for Defamation of Two Solicitors
Table of Contents
A high Court jury in Ireland has found businessman Denis O’Brien and his spokesperson, James Morrissey, liable for defaming two solicitors, Darragh Mackin and Gavin Booth, partners at Belfast firm Phoenix Law. The jury resolute that a 2016 press release issued by O’Brien implied the solicitors acted for the irish Republican army (IRA). https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2024/1121/1456411-denis-obrien-defamation-case/
the jury awarded damages of €411,750 each to Mackin and Booth, totaling €823,500, to compensate for the damage to their professional reputations. The award includes both general and aggravated damages.
Background to the Case
The defamation claim stemmed from a sentence in a press release issued by O’Brien stating: “Sinn Féin/IRA certainly got the report they paid for.” This statement was made in response to a report on media ownership in Ireland. Mackin and Booth were co-authors of the report, which had been commissioned by then-Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/nov/21/denis-obrien-ordered-to-pay-823500-to-solicitors-over-ira-claim
At the time the report was published, O’Brien held critically important stakes in several Irish media companies, creating a potential conflict of interest and fueling the dispute.
The Legal Arguments
O’Brien and Morrissey argued that the statement did not defame the solicitors, nor did it imply they were acting for an unlawful organization. They contended that the phrase was intended to mean the report was biased in favor of Sinn Féin’s political agenda, not that the solicitors were connected to the IRA.
However, after two hours and 20 minutes of deliberation, the jury rejected this defense, concluding that the statement conveyed the meaning that both solicitors were acting for the IRA.
Portrayal and Outcome
The solicitors were represented by Tom Hogan SC, Mark Harty SC, and barrister Conan fegan, with Johnsons Solicitors acting as their instructing solicitors. Darren Lehane SC and barrister Joe Holt,instructed by Meagher Solicitors,represented O’Brien and Morrissey. https://www.irishtimes.com/politics/2024/1121/denis-obrien-must-pay-823500-to-solicitors-over-ira-claim/
This case highlights the serious legal consequences of defamation and the importance of carefully considering the implications of public statements, notably those that could damage an individual’s or organization’s reputation.The ample damages awarded reflect the gravity with which the court viewed the defamatory implications of O’Brien’s statement.
Worth a look