TSN Director of Scouting Craig Button believes there is no one close to challenging Penn State left winger Gavin McKenna in the race to be the first-overall pick in the 2026 NHL Draft.

McKenna is coming off a season where he scored 41 goals with 129 points in 56 games and added nine goals and 38 points in 16 games as the Medicine Hat Tigers captured the Western Hockey league championship.

The Whitehorse, Yukon native is the third-youngest player behind Sidney crosby and John Tavares to capture CHL Player of the Year. McKenna was also awarded CHL and WHL Rookie of the Year honours in 2023-24.

“In my view, there’s nobody close,” said Button of McKenna. “He’s a franchise player. His favorite player is Patrick kane, and he has all those same qualities. He’s a difference-maker, he’s creative.

“He’s got that creativity that can seemingly make something out of what nobody else sees.”

McKenna was the biggest name in the off-season to take advantage of the rule change that allows CHL players to join U.S. college teams.

“he’s been phenomenal in the CHL and the NCAA is going to provide him an outstanding prospect to build on his junior career and to get as ready as possible physically for his debut in the National Hockey League next season,” said Button.

At no. 2 on Button’s list is University of North Dakota defenceman Keaton Verhoeff, who also made the jump to college hockey after skating with the WHL’s Victoria Royals in 2024-25.

As a 16-year-old rookie last season, Verhoeff, who is 6-foot-4 and 212 pounds, had 21 goals and 45 points in 63 games and added 10 points in 11 playoff games. A U17 and U18 gold medallist, he served as captain at the Hlinka Gretzky Cup in August, helping Canada earn bronze.

“Keaton’s got a big presence on the ice,” said Button. “He’s got a physical presence. He’s a competitor. As a 16-year-old player, Keaton showed that willingness to step to the forefront. He did at the U18s en route to Canada winning the gold medal. He was a meaningful factor in that gold-medal win.

“When you have a player that can play every significant situation in the game, hard minutes, hard matchups, those are hard guys to pass on. They become foundations for your team.”

While scouts will be making the trek to watch McKenna and verhoeff in college this season, Button said scouts also need to be beating a path to Finland to watch Tappara in SM-Liiga.

Headlined by defenceman Juho Piiparinen at No. 4, Button has four players in his top 32 who are skating with Tappara this season, including center Oliver Suvanto (No. 21), right winger Vilho Vanhatalo (No. 23) and centre

NHL Draft Prospects – Mid-season Rankings (October 3,2025)

The following is a mid-season ranking of potential NHL draft prospects,based on performance and scouting reports as of October 3,2025. Player statistics are current as of this date.