Dublin Couple Avoids Jail, Agrees to Remove Unauthorised Structures
Frank and Sylvia Gaynor have agreed to dismantle three timber cabins and associated structures on their property in north County Dublin, averting potential imprisonment for contempt of court. The decision came after a warning from Judge John O’Connor of Dublin Circuit Court, who initially threatened jail time if the couple did not devise a plan for compliance.
Years-Long Dispute with Fingal County Council
The case dates back to 2020, with Fingal County Council initiating legal action over unauthorised developments at the Gaynors’ home at Drishoge Manor, Oldtown. In April 2023, the court issued an order requiring the removal of three shed structures, a tarred driveway, a parking area, and a gateway, all erected without the necessary planning permission. Irish Times
Judge’s Warning and Last-Minute Compliance
Judge O’Connor had previously warned Frank Gaynor that he would be jailed if a timeline for compliance wasn’t presented. He even advised Mr. Gaynor to bring a toothbrush to court. During a hearing on March 6th, 2026, the couple initially sought an adjournment to appeal the removal order and requested the judge recuse himself, alleging media bias. Judge O’Connor dismissed the request for recusal, stating he was not influenced by the media. Irish Times
Following a break to consider their position, the Gaynors agreed to remove the unauthorised developments within six months. The judge expressed relief, stating, “No judge wants to send anyone to prison.” Irish Times
Financial Difficulties and Previous Legal Issues
Frank Gaynor had claimed financial hardship, stating he could not afford to remove the structures and that a bank was attempting to repossess his home. However, Judge O’Connor noted the couple’s home appeared “magnificent” and questioned the claim of financial difficulty. Independent.ie
The couple has likewise been linked to more than 30 personal injury claims that were previously dismissed by another court. Roscommon Herald, Irish Sun
Next Steps
Judge O’Connor has requested to see progress in dismantling the structures within the next month. The case has been adjourned for two weeks, at which time the couple will be required to present a detailed plan for the removal of the unauthorised developments. Irish Times