A jury in Collin County is expected to begin deliberations this week in the murder trial of 19-year-old Karmelo Anthony, who is charged in the 2025 fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf. The trial, which centers on a confrontation at a Frisco track meet, has moved to closing arguments as defense attorneys argue the defendant acted in self-defense.
The Case Against Karmelo Anthony
Prosecutors allege that Anthony killed Metcalf during an altercation over a team tent at a track meet. According to police reports cited by NewsNation, the confrontation escalated after Metcalf instructed Anthony to move his belongings from beneath the team’s tent. Investigators claim that Anthony reached into his bag, warned Metcalf, “Touch me and see what happens,” and subsequently stabbed him once in the chest before fleeing the scene. The prosecution presented evidence including the pocket knife recovered from the bleachers and body camera footage showing the speed at which the weapon could be deployed.
Defense Arguments and Self-Defense Claims
Attorneys for Anthony contend that the defendant acted out of fear during a “split-second” encounter. During testimony on Monday, a teammate of Anthony’s told the court the defendant appeared “distraught” immediately following the incident and was heard saying, “I told him not to touch me.” The defense strategy focuses on the claim that Metcalf initiated physical contact, prompting Anthony to react to what he perceived as an imminent threat.
Legal Context: Texas Self-Defense Laws
The trial has highlighted the complexities of Texas law regarding the use of force. While Texas does not utilize “stand your ground” statutes in the same manner as some other jurisdictions, it does maintain laws concerning the right to self-defense and the lack of a duty to retreat. According to Texas defense attorney Todd Shapiro, state law allows individuals to use deadly force if they hold a reasonable belief that they face an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. Under the Texas penal code, 17-year-olds are treated as adults in the criminal justice system, meaning Anthony faces the same potential sentencing guidelines as an adult defendant.
Trial Status and Next Steps
Judge and court officials have sequestered the jury, instructing them to avoid social media and outside discussion regarding the trial. If a verdict is not reached by the close of business Tuesday, jurors will be housed in a hotel and resume deliberations on Wednesday.
The family of the defendant, who was released on a reduced $250,000 bond and moved to an undisclosed location due to threats, continues to maintain his innocence. Conversely, the victim’s father, Jeff Metcalf, has spoken publicly about his son’s character, describing him as a team MVP and high-achieving student. While the elder Metcalf told NewsNation he is pleased the legal process is reaching a conclusion, he acknowledged that a verdict cannot restore his son’s life.
Key Facts at a Glance
- Defendant: Karmelo Anthony, 19.
- Victim: Austin Metcalf, 17.
- Charge: Murder.
- Primary Defense: Self-defense following physical contact initiated by the victim.
- Prosecution Evidence: Recovered pocket knife, body camera footage, and witness testimony.