The New York Rangers have made a bold move, signing star goalie Igor Shesterkin to an eight-year contract extension with an average annual value (AAV) of $11.5 million. But is this contract a stroke of genius or a risky gamble for the franchise?
Is Shesterkin’s Big Deal Worth It?
Shayna Goldman and James Mirtle, both prominent hockey analysts, weigh in on the impact of Shesterkin’s new contract.
Shayna Goldman acknowledges the inherent risk in long-term goalie contracts, citing their unpredictable nature and the challenges of aging. However, she argues that Shesterkin’s exceptional talent and crucial role for the Rangers justify the hefty investment.
She points out that Shesterkin is currently the best goalie in the world, consistently exceeding expectations and carrying the Rangers through crucial playoff runs.
Goldman believes that recent trends in goalie contracts, with players like Jeremy Swayman and Jake Oettinger commanding top dollar despite less established track records, support Shesterkin’s extended deal. Even with the cap hit approaching 12.4 percent of the Rangers’ salary cap, Goldman sees value in signing Shesterkin before his value potentially deflates in free agency.
James Mirtle shares Goldman’s admiration for Shesterkin’s talent and consistency over the past few seasons. He highlights Shesterkin’s superior performance compared to other top goalies and emphasizes his irreplaceable value to the team.
Mirtle also points out that Shesterkin’s age (28) works in the Rangers’ favor, as the contract provides a significant return on investment before he reaches a point where goalies typically decline. The rising salary cap further softens the financial blow of the deal.
Looking at the Rangers’ current standing and their focus on immediate success, Mirtle concludes that locking up Shesterkin long-term makes sense despite the inherent risk.
Letting him enter free agency could have led to a bidding war and potentially losing him to another team.
Both analysts agree that the contract is a delicate balance, carrying both significant risk and potential reward. Ultimately, the success of this deal hinges on Shesterkin’s ability to maintain his elite level of play throughout the eight-year span.
**What are your thoughts on the Shesterkin contract? Share your opinions in the comments below!**