AFL Strips Winmar of Hall of Fame Honors
The Australian Football League Commission has officially expelled former St Kilda champion Nicky Winmar from the Australian Football Hall of Fame. The decision, announced on July 15, 2026, follows Winmar’s recent conviction in the Bendigo Magistrates’ Court on three counts of assaulting a woman.
Commission Cites Charter Amendments
The AFL Commission exercised powers granted by amendments to the Hall of Fame’s charter, which were implemented in 2023. Under these rules, the commission may remove an inductee if they are found guilty of an indictable offense or engage in conduct deemed prejudicial to the interests of the AFL.
AFL Chairman Craig Drummond stated that the commission has a responsibility to maintain the reputation of the honor. “Violence against women has no place. Not in our community, not in our game, and not in the values the Australian Football Hall of Fame seeks to uphold,” Drummond said. He acknowledged Winmar’s historical contributions to the game, including his 251-game career and his role in the fight against racism, but maintained that the recent legal findings rendered his continued membership “inappropriate.”
Winmar Challenges Premature Expulsion
Winmar, 60, has publicly challenged the AFL’s decision, citing the premature nature of the expulsion. He confirmed to News Corp that he intends to appeal the conviction. Winmar questioned the league’s internal consistency, asking for clarity on why he was removed before his legal appeal process has concluded.
The St Kilda Football Club has taken a different approach than the league. While the club suspended Winmar from its own Hall of Fame, it opted not to expel him immediately. In an official statement, the club noted that a final determination regarding his status would be made only after the formal conclusion of the full legal process, including any pending appeals.
Disparate Treatment of Hall of Fame Inductees
The expulsion of Winmar has drawn comparisons to the status of other Hall of Fame members, most notably Wayne Carey. Carey was inducted into the Australian Football Hall of Fame in 2010, three years after he was convicted of assaulting a female police officer in the United States.
The AFL has maintained that the removal of Winmar is not a retroactive application of the 2023 charter amendments. Because Carey’s conviction occurred prior to his induction and the subsequent rule changes, the commission has not moved to strip him of his status. However, the league did block Carey from being inducted as a legend in the New South Wales Australian Football Hall of Fame in 2024, a decision made during a period when the league was publicly emphasizing its stance against violence toward women.
In 2023, the AFL did use its updated powers to remove football great Barry Cable from the Hall of Fame and strip him of his legend status. That decision followed a civil trial in which Cable was found to have sexually abused a girl during his playing career, though he had been found not guilty in a separate criminal trial regarding historical child sex abuse charges.
A Complicated Legacy
Nicky Winmar’s legacy in the sport is defined by his on-field performance and his activism. A highly skilled forward and wingman, he played 251 games for St Kilda and the Western Bulldogs.
He remains one of the most recognizable figures in Australian football history for his 1993 stand at Victoria Park, where he lifted his jumper and pointed to his skin in response to racial abuse from Collingwood supporters. The AFL’s statement on Wednesday explicitly acknowledged this historical contribution, even as it confirmed his removal from the Hall of Fame.
Keep reading