South Korea lacks objective criteria to identify areas with doctor shortages even as it prepares to launch a new regional physician recruitment program next year, the National Assembly Research Service (NARS) said in a report released Tuesday.
The report, authored by researchers Han Jin-ok and Kim Eun-jung, found that current “medically vulnerable area” designations rely on healthcare access and utilization metrics rather than a comprehensive assessment of physician supply and demand. “Physician supply and medical demand by region are not comprehensively evaluated to separately designate areas with doctor shortages,” the report said. “Population-to-physician ratios can show inter-regional gaps, but a single indicator cannot sufficiently reflect patient movement between regions, medical demand by treatment area, or internal regional disparities.” The findings come as the government moves to implement a regional physician recruitment system. The government has said medically vulnerable area designations will factor into deciding how many regional physician slots each area receives. NARS warned that the government is pushing physician placement policies — including residency slot redistribution — without a verified benchmark to set policy priorities or support levels. The report urged development of a Korean-style Physician Uneven Distribution Index (K-PUD) built on the Public Health and Medical Services Act’s Article 12 evaluation framework, according to Doctorsnews. Such an index would combine active physician counts, specialty distribution, regional medical demand, and accessibility indicators to grade shortage severity in stages.
The researchers recommended enshrining the new designation system in Article 12 of the Public Health and Medical Services Act and linking its results directly to physician training and deployment policies. They cautioned that ties to residency quotas should be phased in gradually, citing occupational choice freedoms and social acceptability.
Current vulnerable-area designations are fragmented across multiple statutes. The Public Health and Medical Services Act defines them based on utilization, supply, and accessibility. The Emergency Medical Services Act and Regional Health Act reference vulnerable areas without specific criteria.
The Income Tax Act Enforcement Rules list 58 counties as vulnerable areas for tax exemption purposes, a roster unchanged since 2008. The National Health Insurance Act uses that same tax-law list to set differentiated reimbursement rates.
NARS called for consolidating these divergent standards under the Public Health and Medical Services Act, with the Emergency Medical Services Act and Regional Health Act referencing its evaluation results.
The report also said the Special Act on Strengthening Essential Medical Care and Reducing Regional Medical Gaps should align its “essential medical vulnerable area” designations with the existing framework, incorporating treatment-area supply-utilization data and self-sufficiency rates.