ESPN analyst Stephen A. Smith issued a public apology to New York Knicks stars Jalen Brunson and Josh Hart during a live taping of “The Roommates Show” at Madison Square Garden on June 21, 2024. The appearance addressed long-standing friction stemming from Smith’s past on-air criticism of the players’ professional potential.
### Why fans booed Stephen A. Smith at MSG
The crowd at the Infosys Theater greeted Smith with loud, sustained boos as he took the stage alongside hosts Jalen Brunson and Josh Hart. The negative reaction from the New York faithful was largely tied to Smith’s history of questioning the team’s roster decisions and the players’ individual capabilities.
Smith, a prominent voice on ESPN’s “First Take,” has frequently challenged the Knicks’ front office moves. His skepticism toward Brunson dates back to the guard’s 2022 signing, when Smith questioned whether Brunson was a “star” caliber player capable of leading the franchise. Before that, in 2016, Smith famously dismissed the Villanova Wildcats—a team that featured future NBA players including Brunson, Hart, Mikal Bridges, and Donte DiVincenzo—by claiming they lacked “a real NBA prospect.”
### How Smith addressed the criticism
During the live podcast, both Brunson and Hart pressed Smith to account for his past comments. Smith acknowledged his misjudgments, telling the audience he was “beyond wrong” regarding his evaluation of the players’ careers.
“I’m a man. I’m a grown man. When you’re wrong, you’re wrong,” Smith stated during the exchange. He extended an apology not only to the players but to the entire Knicks organization, noting the team’s success has rendered his previous critiques inaccurate.
### The context of the “Roommates Show” tension
The live event highlighted the shifting dynamic between traditional sports media and current athletes who control their own platforms. While Smith has built a career on provocative commentary, the rise of podcasts like “The Roommates Show” allows players to directly confront analysts and provide their own perspectives.
| Criticism Target | Smith’s Past Stance | Current Outcome |
| :— | :— | :— |
| 2016 Villanova Squad | “No real NBA prospects” | Produced multiple NBA starters |
| Jalen Brunson (2022) | “Not the answer” | All-NBA level performance |
The confrontation serves as a point of closure for a narrative that has followed Brunson and Hart since they entered the league. By inviting Smith to the stage, the players utilized their platform to address the skepticism head-on in front of a home crowd.
Related reading