Dustin Johnson’s US Open Resurgence Contrasts with LIV Golf Struggles

Dustin Johnson, the 2016 US Open champion, posted a 66 in the second round of the 2024 US Open at Shinnecock Hills, moving to -4 and tying for second, according to PGA Tour coverage. The performance marked a stark contrast to his earlier struggles on the LIV Golf circuit, where he had missed the cut in three major tournaments in 2023. Johnson’s resurgence has sparked renewed debate about his competitive form following his 2022 move to LIV Golf, a breakaway tour backed by Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund.

Johnson’s LIV Golf Challenges and Recent Comeback

Johnson’s transition to LIV Golf was initially met with skepticism, as he struggled to maintain his elite form. In 2023, he missed the cut at the Masters, U.S. Open, and PGA Championship, leading to speculation that his move to the LIV Tour had compromised his focus. However, his recent results suggest a reversal. After a 33rd-place finish at the Masters and a 44th at the U.S. PGA Championship, Johnson secured a fourth-place finish at LIV Golf Korea in May and a fifth-place finish at LIV Golf Andalucia in June, according to LIV Golf’s official website. These results, coupled with his strong start at the 2024 US Open, have reignited discussions about his longevity in the sport.

“It’s been six years since his last major win, but Rory McIlroy’s 11-year gap between his fourth and fifth majors shows that age isn’t a barrier,” said golf analyst Mark O’Meara, citing a historical comparison. “Johnson’s performance this year suggests he’s still in the conversation.”

Contrasting Fortunes: Johnson vs. Bryson DeChambeau and Jon Rahm

While Johnson’s second-round 66 kept him in contention, other top players faced challenges. Bryson DeChambeau, a LIV Golf rival, recorded a double bogey on hole four, dropping to +2, according to ESPN’s live coverage. In contrast, Jon Rahm remained bogey-free through two rounds, posting a 67 to remain at -3. Rahm, the 2023 U.S. Open champion, has been a consistent performer this season, including a third-place finish at the Canadian Open in June.

“Rahm’s ability to maintain composure under pressure is a key factor in his success,” said PGA Tour analyst Brandel Chamblee. “DeChambeau’s recent struggles highlight the volatility of the LIV Tour, where form can shift rapidly.”

Gary Woodland’s Mental Health Journey and US Open Comeback

Another standout at Shinnecock was Gary Woodland, who opened with a 67 and followed with a birdie on the first hole. Woodland, who publicly discussed his battle with PTSD after brain surgery in 2023, has shown resilience. He won the Houston Open in March, ending a seven-year PGA Tour victory drought, according to Golf Digest. His performance at the 2024 US Open, where he tied for third after two rounds, has drawn praise from fans and fellow players.

“Woodland’s story is one of perseverance,” said PGA Tour spokesperson Jane Cronin. “His ability to compete at a high level despite his challenges is inspiring.”

US Open Scoring Averages and Historical Context

The first-round scoring average at Shinnecock was 73.28, slightly higher than the 71.40 average at the 2023 U.S. Open but lower than the 74.64 at Oakmont in 2025. This year’s course setup, described as “tough” by officials, has tested players’ adaptability. Wyndham Clark, the overnight leader, maintained a 6-under-par 64, according to Golf Channel’s coverage, while Johnson’s 66 closed the gap.

“The US Open’s reputation for difficulty is well-earned,” said former champion Ernie Els. “Players like Clark and Johnson who thrive here often have the mental toughness to handle adversity.”

What’s Next for Johnson and the LIV Tour?

Johnson’s performance at the 2024 US Open has cast doubt on narratives that his LIV Golf move diminished his competitiveness. However, the tour’s continued growth and the 2025 PGA Tour schedule remain key factors. With the U.S. Open’s final round approaching, Johnson’s ability to maintain his form will be critical. Meanwhile, players like Rahm and Woodland continue to challenge for the title, underscoring the event’s unpredictability.

“This tournament is a test of skill, mental strength, and adaptability,” said PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan. “The players who rise to the occasion will be the ones remembered.”