California Billionaire Tax Defeat Follows Deep Labor Rifts
What a waste of resources and what a squandering of an opportunity,
said Jim Mangia, president of a health clinic chain supporting the measure, as California’s landmark wealth tax headed toward defeat. Despite a national backdrop of populist victories elsewhere, the state’s proposed tax on billionaires faltered in deep-blue territory amid intense infighting among labor leaders and millions spent by opponents.
Sen. Bernie Sanders called the initiative the most important ballot initiative in America, designed to test whether rising anger over income inequality could translate into policy. Instead, the campaign was undone by a lack of broad consensus among the coalition that typically backs progressive tax measures. Proponents faced an expensive opposition campaign that poured more than $300 million into defeating the proposal.
Labor Fractures and Opposition Spending Undermine Proposition 40
Long before opponents mobilized significant financial resistance, labor leaders were sharply divided over the proposal. The ballot measure directed nearly all of its generated revenue specifically toward health care. Its primary sponsor pushed ahead without building a broad consensus among allied groups, which alienated natural partners.
Jim Mangia pointed out that the lack of coalition-building alienated potential supporters. There was no coalition, they pissed off everyone, and so many of those natural allies that would’ve supported it refused,
Mangia said. Dave Regan, leader of the health care workers’ union SEIU-UHW, spearheaded the initiative after President Donald Trump signed legislation that slashed health care spending, prompting fears of widespread job losses and hospital closures.
Opposition from prominent establishment figures further damaged the campaign’s prospects. Governor Gavin Newsom consistently opposed state-level wealth taxes, while unions representing teachers and firefighters also withheld support. California Labor Federation President Lorena Gonzalez noted that divisions within labor unions made it exceptionally difficult to advance a working-class agenda.
Union Leaders Vow to Fight Billionaire Influence and Return in 2028
Proponents did not wait for final election results to acknowledge the outcome. In a statement on X, the union sponsoring the measure conceded that it appeared unlikely to pass. At a Tuesday night press conference, Dave Regan vowed to continue fighting the political influence of billionaires and suggested he could return to the ballot in 2028.
Regan argued that hundreds of millions of dollars in opposition spending created confusion among voters who understood the underlying equity issues.
Keep reading