International Edition
Latest News
News

Wyoming Llama Outfitter Sues Forest Service Over YouTube Video Ban in Wilderness

A Wyoming llama outfitter and a wilderness-access group sued the U.S. Forest Service on Wednesday, alleging the agency violated the First Amendment by treating a YouTube video of a hunting trip as illegal commercial filming in a designated…

Wyoming Llama Outfitter Sues Forest Service Over YouTube Video Ban in Wilderness

A Wyoming llama outfitter and a wilderness-access group sued the U.S. Forest Service on Wednesday, alleging the agency violated the First Amendment by treating a YouTube video of a hunting trip as illegal commercial filming in a designated wilderness area.

The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for Wyoming by Joshua Smunk and the BlueRibbon Coalition, names Shoshone National Forest Supervisor Kenneth Coffin, wilderness manager William Frost and the Forest Service as defendants.

Smunk, CEO of Clark-based Hooves, Horns & Hideaways, participated in a two-week elk hunt in the Shoshone National Forest in September 2025 and supplied three of the eight pack llamas used on the trip.

One of the hunters recorded the outing and later published it as an episode of the PEAX Thrive Vodcast on YouTube, where Smunk and another traveler described nighttime encounters with grizzly bears, black bears and wolves. A man in the video says he and Smunk offer llama rentals in Cody, Wyoming, and Red Lodge, Montana.

According to the complaint, Forest Service officials invited Smunk to an in-person meeting on about March 19 to discuss his request for a permit for his guiding business. “Instead of answering Josh’s questions regarding his permit request, Defendant Frost began accusing Josh of violating the Wilderness Act,” the document says.

Smunk was told the hunting video “ran afoul of the commercial filming prohibition because the video was subsequently monetized on YouTube,” though he was not the person who posted or monetized it. Authorities claimed the footage served as an advertisement for his operation because one of his llamas, visible in the background, functioned as a “prop” for the business.

The Washington Times reports that a Forest Service law enforcement officer told Smunk: “Your llamas were used as props in the video, and that’s illegal.” The outlet writes that the agency holds it is a violation of federal statute to “monetize” any photography or videography conducted in a federally designated wilderness area.

Breaches of the Wilderness Act can bring a ban on public-land use, imprisonment of up to six months and fines of up to $5,000; Smunk received a warning.

When Smunk asked whether the recently enacted EXPLORE Act allowed commercial filming on federal lands, he was told, “The Wilderness Act takes precedence over the EXPLORE Act.”

Asked if he could film strictly for personal use, the response was: “You can film BUT [it] has to be for your personal use — just like we explained that day here at the office.” Asked what would happen if he received a quarter-cent per view on YouTube, officials said: “You can not monetize it thru ‘clicks,’ etc.”

The agency confirmed it actively monitors social media channels to identify people who have monetized content filmed in wilderness areas. “As people post these types of ‘commercial’ filming products, and we find them, we do go after them,” the officer said. The paper notes such permits are rarely issued — “think one every couple of years” — and are never issued for hunting films.

“Congress never intended for federal agencies to adopt commercial-filming regulations that would reach every person with a smartphone, or that would come to meaningfully suppress core First Amendment expression,” the complaint says.

“The goal was far different, and far more circumscribed: If big companies with big operations want to use wilderness areas for their films, the government needs to be able to regulate those operations and, perhaps, obtain some return for renting out certain federal property.”

Shoshone National Forest, established in 1891, was the first federally protected National Forest in the United States and covers nearly 2,500,000 acres in Wyoming. It forms part of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem, a nearly unbroken expanse of federally protected lands encompassing an estimated 20,000,000 acres.

Within the forest there are five wilderness areas, which protect more than half of the total area of managed land from development. The forest is notably inhabited by nearly all animal species found in North America, including grizzly bear, gray wolf and elk — the very wildlife featured in the hunting video at the center of the lawsuit.

Smunk and the BlueRibbon Coalition are petitioning the court to prevent the Forest Service and Shoshone National Forest officials from invoking the Wilderness Act of 1964 to bar them from filming any videos in the forest that might later be monetized on platforms such as YouTube. Wyoming-based attorney Amy Iberlin represents the plaintiffs alongside Texas-based attorneys Robert Henneke, Chance Weldon, Matt Miller and Heidi Walusimbi of the Texas Public Policy Foundation.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.