Controversial Calls in Corinthians-Flamengo Match Draw Debate Among Former Referees

São Paulo, Brazil – March 23, 2026 – The Brazilian Série A match between Corinthians and Flamengo, which ended in a 1-1 draw on Sunday, has sparked significant debate regarding several officiating decisions. Former referees have weighed in on a contested expulsion and a potential penalty, offering differing perspectives on the key incidents.

Everton Araújo’s Expulsion

Flamengo’s midfielder, Everton Araújo, received a straight red card in the second half after a challenge on Corinthians’ Breno Bidon. The on-field decision was upheld after review by the Video Assistant Referee (VAR).

Alfredo Loebeling believes the expulsion was incorrect, stating, “The foot doesn’t reach over, it’s a tackle, it takes part of the ball, there’s nothing to justify the red card.” He further commented that the referee initially showed a red card seemingly to provoke VAR intervention, which then correctly supported the original decision.

Guilherme Ceretta, a referee based in the USA, disagreed, arguing the expulsion was justified due to “disproportionate force” in the tackle. Emídio Marques also supported the decision, citing excessive force.

Possible Penalty for Corinthians

Corinthians appealed for a penalty in the second half when André fell during a challenge with Ayrton Lucas inside the penalty area. However, the on-field referee did not award a penalty, and the VAR did not recommend a review.

According to reports, there was contact, leading some to believe a penalty should have been awarded.

Expert Analysis

The differing opinions highlight the subjective nature of officiating and the challenges faced by referees in making split-second decisions. The incident underscores the ongoing scrutiny of VAR and its impact on game outcomes.

Source: UOL Esporte https://www.uol.com.br/esporte/futebol/ultimas-noticias/2026/03/23/corinthians-x-flamengo-ex-arbitros.htm