The International Court of Justice found Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya on Thursday, the first time the court has ever held a state responsible for the crime.
The ruling came after a 2017 military campaign in Rakhine State killed thousands and forced more than 700,000 Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh, NOS Nieuws reported. The court began its session at 10:00 a.m. and the judgment that Myanmar had committed genocide was pronounced around 12:30 p.m., according to Reformatorisch Dagblad.
Presiding Yuji Iwasawa said the court concluded Myanmar’s security forces had killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, committed widespread sexual violence and extreme violence against children, and attacked fleeing Rohingya. The 15-judge bench ruled that Myanmar had committed genocide, NRC reported.
The court ordered Myanmar to allow the safe return of refugees, to preserve evidence, and to pay reparations. Gambia’s Dawda Jallow said the decision vindicated survivors. “They have survived, they have given testimony and today they were believed,” he told reporters, according to Reformatorisch Dagblad. Jallow expressed his deep gratitude for the court’s willingness to “hold Myanmar accountable.”
In past cases, the court required proof that a state acted solely to destroy a group; the Myanmar ruling establishes that a legitimate military objective does not automatically exclude a finding of genocide, University of Amsterdam Kyra Wigard told NOS Nieuws.
“The fact that a state has a legitimate military goal does not automatically mean that genocide is excluded. Wigard added that the court explicitly weighed the violence used, including violence against children and sexual violence, in assessing genocidal intent, something that had never been done so extensively in a case before.”
The decision was not unanimous on the genocide finding. Nine judges voted to convict; six dissented. André Nollkaemper, professor of international law at the University of Amsterdam, cautioned that the split bench means the precedent is not yet settled. “Those judges with a dissenting opinion are not the least significant,” he told NRC. “Therefore this ruling is not yet set in stone.”
Implications for the Israel-Gaza case
The ruling is expected to shape the pending case South Africa brought against Israel in 2023, alleging genocide in Gaza. Both Myanmar and Israel argued they were targeting terrorists, not an ethnic or religious group. The court rejected that defense in the Myanmar case, stating that intent to commit genocide can coexist with other motives.
Israel has not yet reacted. South Africa must submit its evidence by November 2025; oral hearings are not expected before late 2029, NOS Nieuws reported. Eleven other countries, including the Netherlands, Germany, and France, later joined the Myanmar case through a declaration of intervention, AD reported.

South Africa must submit its evidence by November 2025; oral hearings are not expected before late 2029, NOS Nieuws reported.
ICJ lacks enforcement power as Security Council blocks action
The ICJ has no enforcement mechanism. Compliance depends on the UN Security Council, where permanent members China and Russia support Myanmar’s military junta, Reformatorisch Dagblad noted. The United States, also a permanent member, does not recognize the court’s compulsory jurisdiction. Gambia can turn to the UN Security Council in the event of non-compliance, but will undoubtedly meet resistance there, the outlet added.
Peter Saiful, a Rohingya Christian leader in the Cox’s Bazar refugee camps, welcomed the recognition but stressed that justice remains incomplete. “More than ten thousand Rohingya — among them Muslims, Hindus and Christians — have been murdered, purely because of who they are,” he told Reformatorisch Dagblad via WhatsApp.
“We express our sincere thanks to the ICJ and to the lawyers who have tirelessly advocated for our community.” Saiful, who describes himself as a defender of the human rights of the Rohingya, remains hopeful that world leaders will increase pressure on the regime and withdraw all support until full justice is achieved.
Myanmar, the largest country in Mainland Southeast Asia with a population of about 51 million, borders Bangladesh where Rohingya refugees fled. Formerly known as Burma until the military government changed the English name in 1989, it gained independence in 1948 after British colonial rule.
The country has endured decades of military dominance, including a 1962 coup that established a dictatorship and a 2021 coup that sparked an ongoing civil war, displacing over 3.5 million people internally and creating more than 1.3 million refugees and asylum seekers.
Smeulers added a caveat: the court’s judgment is a legal determination, not the only one that matters. “For the question of whether there is genocide we do not necessarily have to wait for this,” she told NOS Nieuws. “Genocide scholars, a UN commission and rapporteurs have already issued legally well-founded opinions on this.”
Earlier coverage: UN Court Set to Deliver Historic Genocide Verdict on Myanmar Rohingya Case
More on Rakhine State
Related reading