Mattarella Urges Respect Among Italian Institutions Amid Justice System Tensions

Rome – In an unprecedented move, Italian President Sergio Mattarella addressed a plenary session of the Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSM) on Wednesday, February 18, 2026, to emphasize the need for mutual respect among the nation’s institutions. The intervention comes amid heightened tensions surrounding proposed justice reforms and a controversial debate over the role of the judiciary.

Unusual Presidential Appearance at CSM

President Mattarella’s appearance at the ordinary CSM session was described as “unusual” and marked a significant institutional moment. He stated he had not attended a regular CSM meeting in his eleven-year term, explaining he was prompted to do so by “the need and desire to underscore, once again, the value of the CSM’s constitutionally significant role.” Unioneonline

Call for Institutional Respect

The President stressed “the need and intention to reaffirm the respect that must be nurtured and shown – particularly by other institutions – towards this institution.” LaPresse This appeal for respect extended to all branches of government – legislative, executive, and judicial – acknowledging that all institutions are subject to criticism and possess inherent “defects, gaps, and errors.”

Context of Rising Tensions

Mattarella’s address followed recent public statements that have inflamed tensions within the Italian justice system. Justice Minister Carlo Nordio had referenced a speech by anti-mafia magistrate Nino di Matteo, describing the judiciary’s self-governing body as a “para-mafia system,” prompting a strong reaction from the National Magistrates’ Association (ANM). Unioneonline Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni as well recently criticized a “section of the politicized judiciary” for allegedly obstructing the government’s policies, particularly on immigration. Unioneonline

Nordio Responds to Mattarella’s Appeal

Minister of Justice Carlo Nordio expressed his appreciation for President Mattarella’s call for mutual respect, stating that he would ensure the debate surrounding the upcoming referendum on justice reform remains “within the limits of a healthy, calm and respectful opposition.” Unioneonline

Looking Ahead

President Mattarella’s intervention is seen as an effort to de-escalate tensions and promote a more constructive dialogue as Italy approaches a crucial referendum on justice reform scheduled for March 22 and 23. La Milano His message underscores the importance of maintaining respect between institutions for the proper functioning of the Italian Republic.