Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has challenged the European Union’s diplomatic consistency, specifically citing a recent phone call between Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre, Finnish President Alexander Stubb, and Russian President Vladimir Putin. In a letter sent Thursday to European Council President Antonio Costa, Meloni argued that such independent diplomatic initiatives create an image of a divided and disorganized Europe, which she believes undermines the continent’s credibility in addressing the war in Ukraine. The Italian leader noted that frequent meetings in various formats make it unclear who speaks on behalf of the EU, leading to a perception of a continent that lacks the credibility to manage one of the most difficult issues facing member nations.
Concerns Over Diplomatic Coordination
Meloni pointed to the Putin call, alongside other recent meetings in Miami, Oslo, and Brussels, as evidence of a fractured European approach. She stated that the appearance of a "Europe in mess and disorder" only serves the interests of those who wish for the conflict to continue. Meloni is seeking a formal, written commitment that she will not support this "dynamic" of uncoordinated diplomacy. She emphasized that she is not requesting a specific role for Italy, but rather demanding that the EU clearly define who is authorized to negotiate on its behalf and under what mandate. She warned that without such clarity, Europe risks becoming irrelevant in the peace process.
Reactions to the Putin Call
The phone conversation between Støre, Stubb, and Putin—which took place last week and lasted 90 minutes—has drawn varied responses. Prime Minister Støre told NRK that he and President Stubb delivered "very clear messages" to the Russian leader, noting that the call was made in consultation with Ukraine. Støre maintained that he informed Norway’s partners of the call in advance and argued that the United States should not be the only voice representing Western interests. He explained that although the conversation required translation between English and Russian, it covered the current situation and allowed the leaders to present viewpoints they knew Ukraine wanted conveyed. Following the call with Putin, Støre and Stubb also spoke with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyj, who had requested the two leaders hold the conversation with the Russian president.
However, the initiative faced immediate criticism from Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen. Frederiksen publicly questioned the decision to act "Alone" rather than maintaining a unified European front, an outburst that sparked surprise among those who value Nordic unity during crises. The situation has highlighted underlying tensions within Nordic cooperation, with some analysts noting that such public disagreements reflect a region moving away from traditional diplomatic consensus toward more individual national interests. Political editor Kjetil Alstadheim of Aftenposten notably responded to Frederiksen’s criticism by writing, Shut up, Mette!
(Shut up, Mette!), a remark that drew significant attention in Danish media.
The Search for a Unified European Voice
EU foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas addressed the criticism during a meeting in Lisbon. Kallas expressed agreement with the sentiment that the union should not speak with multiple, conflicting voices. She stated that Europe needs to remain united to ensure its influence, noting that if the continent remains consistent in its messaging, it is more likely to be taken into account by other global powers. She emphasized that Russia’s goals for the region require a unified European response.
Next Steps for EU Diplomacy
Meloni has requested that the issue of diplomatic representation be added to the agenda of an informal EU summit in Dublin next week. She aims for a definitive decision to be reached by member states in December regarding how the bloc handles future negotiations. As northern Europe remains one of Ukraine’s closest supporters, including Denmark, the diplomatic friction highlights the difficulty of maintaining a single front while individual nations manage their own security assessments and communication channels.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Why does the Italian Prime Minister want a written agreement?
Meloni stated she wants it formally recorded that she will not support the current "disorganized" approach to diplomacy, as she fears it makes Europe irrelevant in the peace process. -
What was the duration and nature of the call with Vladimir Putin?
The call between Prime Minister Støre, President Stubb, and President Putin lasted 90 minutes. Støre described the conversation as a formal exchange where he and Stubb delivered clear messages regarding the war, rather than a heated debate. -
Are there other meetings impacting this discussion?
Yes, Meloni highlighted a series of security-focused meetings held recently in Miami, Oslo, and Brussels as part of the "messy" diplomatic landscape that she believes necessitates a more centralized EU strategy.
Related reading