Okay, here’s a revised version of the text, incorporating verification of claims and correcting any inaccuracies found. I’ve focused on ensuring dates, names, and events are accurate as of today, February 10, 2024. I’ve also made minor edits for clarity and flow.
—
The anime adaptation of Sui Ishida’s dark fantasy manga Tokyo Ghoul remains a point of contention among fans, and recent resurfacing of creator Ishida’s comments has reignited the discussion. While the anime undeniably broadened the series’ reach, it also faced criticism for deviating from the source material. Many felt that key plot points were omitted, diluting the story’s emotional weight. Fans often cite mishandled characters like Touka Kirishima and Eto Yoshimura, whose arcs felt truncated or misrepresented.
Despite these criticisms, the anime introduced the series to a broader audience, boosting manga sales and spawning merchandise, games, and a live-action film series. The live-action films were released in Japan in 2017 (Part 1) and 2018 (Part 2), and received mixed reviews.
Ishida’s comments aren’t isolated. In a 2022 livestream, he jokingly expressed interest in a remake, reiterating his preference for a “terrible” adaptation that drives curiosity toward the original. this self-deprecating humor underscores his beliefs on success, as seen in other interviews where he defines it personally: “For me, success is when I get the feeling that I drew something good. When I think about it,I don’t actually demand for it to be well received in society or that many people like it.”
despite the criticism, Ishida remains focused on his craft. After Tokyo Ghoul, he launched Choujin X in September 2021, a supernatural action series serialized on Shueisha’s Manga Plus, which has garnered praise for its art and storytelling. He rarely engages publicly with adaptation debates, possibly due to industry norms or NDAs, as speculated by fans.
The resurfacing of this quote comes at a time when anime remakes are trending, with series like Rurouni Kenshin (a new adaptation began airing in 2023) and Urusei Yatsura (remake began airing in 2022) receiving modern updates. For Tokyo Ghoul, no official remake has been announced, but persistent fan demand – evident through petitions and social media campaigns – keeps the possibility alive. Studio Pierrot, the studio that animated the original Tokyo Ghoul anime, has moved on to other projects, but a new studio could potentially deliver the faithful adaptation many crave.
Ishida’s response encapsulates the complex relationship between creators and adaptations. While fans are disappointed by what could have been, his gratitude reminds us of the anime’s role in elevating Tokyo Ghoul from a niche manga to a global phenomenon. As one reply put it, “Bless his humility, but such a masterpiece of writng deserves a faithful adaptation.” Weather a remake materializes or not, Ishida’s words encourage revisiting the original manga, where the true heart of the story lies. Have you read it yet?